{ "claims": [ { "boundary": "僅確認媒體所載公告內容，不能據此認定搜索影響續租或造成歇業。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-1" ], "id": "claim-commander-d-search-rights-93f35e1349f4", "scope": { "geography": "臺北市西門町Commander D", "population": "店家公布的營業安排", "time": "2026年11月1日報導，公告營業至11月8日" }, "status": "supported", "text": "媒體轉載的店家公告說明租約到期、營業至2026年11月8日。" }, { "boundary": "不能把公布懲處視為對搜身、上銬及帶回逐項合法性的認定，也不能推定內部調查僅處理言詞。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-3" ], "id": "claim-commander-d-search-rights-299a5c7dd560", "scope": { "geography": "臺北市萬華分局Commander D搜索勤務", "population": "受懲處的4名員警與兩名主管", "time": "2026年10月3日勤務、10月5日懲處報導" }, "status": "supported", "text": "公開懲處理由對應4名員警的不當發言，以及兩名主管的制止與督導責任。" }, { "boundary": "現場管制與帶往警局須分開檢驗；這不排除符合其他法定要件時可以強制到場。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-5", "e-src-8" ], "id": "claim-commander-d-search-rights-cb2de15ee6a8", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣", "population": "搜索現場人員及被要求前往警局者", "time": "截至2026年11月4日稿件所引法條" }, "status": "supported", "text": "搜索時依法可以禁止在場人員離去，但搜索票本身沒有授權帶走多少人的額度。" }, { "boundary": "支持衣著被用作篩選依據，不能證明衣著是唯一因素，也不能證明警方所稱跡證確實存在。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-3", "e-src-9", "e-src-10", "e-src-11", "e-src-12" ], "id": "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ca2e28507226", "scope": { "geography": "臺北市西門町Commander D", "population": "被帶回的51名顧客", "time": "2026年10月3日搜索及其後報導" }, "status": "supported", "text": "多家報導把被帶回的51名顧客與裸露上身連結；路透社供稿並轉述警方因無法判斷誰涉入而帶回赤膊者。" }, { "boundary": "見報日期不能完整還原發言先後；不能據此認定警方有意改口，或確定每人在各階段的筆錄身分與處分。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-3", "e-src-9", "e-src-10", "e-src-11", "e-src-12", "e-src-16" ], "id": "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ba4444943b00", "scope": { "geography": "臺北市Commander D及萬華分局", "population": "被帶回的51名顧客", "time": "2026年10月4日至23日見報說法" }, "status": "supported", "text": "同一批51人見報過涉嫌違反社維法、裁處或送辦，以及證人、自願、未裁罰等不同說法。" }, { "boundary": "這是依公開報導作出的暫定推論；在場者自述未經獨立證實，不能認定全體遭違法拘束。出發前自由同意或個別合法強制依據的紀錄可能改變判斷。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-11", "e-src-13" ], "id": "claim-commander-d-search-rights-15b647ffc21c", "scope": { "geography": "臺北市Commander D至警局的同行過程", "population": "被要求同行的顧客，尤其報導涉及的部分在場者", "time": "2026年10月3日" }, "status": "synthesis", "text": "公開線索使我們有理由懷疑，至少部分顧客未獲真正的同行選擇。" }, { "boundary": "聲明代表參與團體立場，不代表全體同志，也不使其中的現場指控自動成為已證實事實。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-4", "e-src-7" ], "id": "claim-commander-d-search-rights-78f29c389f1f", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣，針對臺北市Commander D事件", "population": "兩份聯合聲明的參與團體", "time": "2026年10月4日及20日" }, "status": "supported", "text": "兩份團體聲明要求檢驗執法措施、保存與公開可揭露紀錄、追究責任並改善程序保障。" }, { "boundary": "詳細同意程序針對涉嫌犯罪者；不能直接當成臺灣證人的現行規範，也未建立其減少強迫或歧視的成效。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-24", "e-src-25" ], "id": "claim-commander-d-search-rights-5f45cd7c0273", "scope": { "geography": "英格蘭與威爾斯", "population": "自願接受警方詢問者，詳細保障以涉嫌犯罪者為主", "time": "稿件引用的官方告知書及2023年版Code C" }, "status": "supported", "text": "英格蘭與威爾斯的官方告知書及Code C，具體說明自願詢問的離開權利，並對涉嫌犯罪者要求告知、確認同意及留下紀錄。" } ], "evidence": [ { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-30d52fb2bc98" ], "id": "e-src-1", "locator": "2026年11月1日報導所引店家公告：租約到期，營業至11月8日。", "source_id": "src-1", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-93f35e1349f4" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-2", "locator": "內文關於2026年10月3日萬華分局持搜索票搜索 Commander D、帶回51名顧客及負責人送辦的段落。", "source_id": "src-2", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-73bd33af9a96" ], "id": "e-src-3", "locator": "2026年10月5日報導中，林炎田說明檢視41段蒐證影像、4名員警各申誡兩次，以及帶隊偵查隊長與分局長懲處的段落。", "source_id": "src-3", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-299a5c7dd560", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ba4444943b00", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ca2e28507226" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-4", "locator": "10月20日聲明中，指控搜身、使用戒具及強制帶回的段落。", "source_id": "src-4", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-78f29c389f1f" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-5", "locator": "《刑事訴訟法》第128條。", "source_id": "src-5", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-cb2de15ee6a8" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-85dbb9e9e77e", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-9b9874df3d2a" ], "id": "e-src-6", "locator": "10月29日市府新聞稿中，行政調查報告已獲警政署核復，以及執法指引、權益說明與法律心理支持的說明。", "source_id": "src-6", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-7", "locator": "10月4日聯合聲明中，承認偵辦特定案件必要性、要求最小侵害，以及列出五項要求的段落。", "source_id": "src-7", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-78f29c389f1f" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-8", "locator": "《刑事訴訟法》第144條：執行搜索或扣押時封鎖現場、禁止在場人員離去的規定。", "source_id": "src-8", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-cb2de15ee6a8" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-9", "locator": "內文關於現場超過百人、其中51人裸露上身，以及依社維法處理「裸身的51人」的段落。", "source_id": "src-9", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ba4444943b00", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ca2e28507226" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-10", "locator": "內文關於將有裸露身體的51名客人帶回製作筆錄的段落。", "source_id": "src-10", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ba4444943b00", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ca2e28507226" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-494347ccbef6" ], "id": "e-src-11", "locator": "內文「51名脫上衣的民眾帶回警局」的段落。", "source_id": "src-11", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-15b647ffc21c", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ba4444943b00", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ca2e28507226" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-12", "locator": "內文引述偵查隊長說明：無法當場判斷誰涉及性或猥褻行為，因此帶回打赤膊者，並傾向不對51人罰款的段落。", "source_id": "src-12", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ba4444943b00", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ca2e28507226" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-494347ccbef6", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-73bd33af9a96" ], "id": "e-src-13", "locator": "2026年10月30日刊出的在場者訪談，關於搜身、衣著及被帶回過程的當事人自述。", "source_id": "src-13", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-15b647ffc21c" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-494347ccbef6" ], "id": "e-src-14", "locator": "《社會秩序維護法》第42條：即時制止、逕行通知到場、不服通知時強制到場及但書例外。", "source_id": "src-14", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-15", "locator": "《社會秩序維護法》第41條、第42條及第83條；其中第83條為任意裸體、妨害善良風俗且不聽勸阻的規定。", "source_id": "src-15", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-494347ccbef6", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-73bd33af9a96", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-9b9874df3d2a" ], "id": "e-src-16", "locator": "內文關於被帶回顧客未受裁罰的警方說法。", "source_id": "src-16", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ba4444943b00" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-17", "locator": "《刑事訴訟法》第196條之1：司法警察官或司法警察通知證人到場詢問的規定。", "source_id": "src-17", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-18", "locator": "《刑事訴訟法》第175條：傳喚證人使用傳票的規定。", "source_id": "src-18", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-19", "locator": "《刑事訴訟法》第178條：證人經合法傳喚，無正當理由不到場的處理。", "source_id": "src-19", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-20", "locator": "《刑事訴訟法》第95條：罪名、緘默權、選任辯護人及請求調查有利證據等告知事項。", "source_id": "src-20", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-21", "locator": "處理辦法第27條，關於詢問時的程序保障。", "source_id": "src-21", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-22", "locator": "法規全文中，關於詢問錄音、急迫例外記明筆錄，以及未錄音或錄音不完整時主管查明的規定。", "source_id": "src-22", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-cedaa71575c8" ], "id": "e-src-23", "locator": "警政署2024年向立法院提出的書面報告，第1至2頁：未受逮捕或拘提的犯罪嫌疑人得離去，以及新增告知義務的答覆。", "source_id": "src-23", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-442bffe7e45a" ], "id": "e-src-24", "locator": "官方自願詢問權利告知書中，關於無須同意詢問、同意前告知權利、未被逮捕可隨時離開及免費法律協助的內容。", "source_id": "src-24", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-5f45cd7c0273" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-442bffe7e45a" ], "id": "e-src-25", "locator": "PACE Code C（2023）第3.21至3.22B段：自願協助調查、限制離去、徵求及確認同意，以及告知與同意紀錄。", "source_id": "src-25", "supports": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-5f45cd7c0273" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-442bffe7e45a" ], "id": "e-src-26", "locator": "官方統計報告第5.5.1節，關於自願詢問資料的漏記與重複紀錄限制。", "source_id": "src-26", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-0b4300e845bf" ], "id": "e-src-27", "locator": "內文刊載的警方書面回應：多次檢舉、轄區特性、性別課程參訓涵蓋率91.78%，以及否認針對特定群體的說明。", "source_id": "src-27", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-0b4300e845bf" ], "id": "e-src-28", "locator": "「取締妨害風化場所件數」資料集的欄位說明：機關、單位、件數等欄位。", "source_id": "src-28", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-9b9874df3d2a" ], "id": "e-src-29", "locator": "劉耀仁2026年10月5日書面質詢中，要求警察局提出改善報告及執行期程的內容。", "source_id": "src-29", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-30", "locator": "2026年9月11日質詢當日報導中，洪健益提出涉及未成年人等指控、店家否認，以及蔣萬安要求嚴查嚴辦的段落。", "source_id": "src-30", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-31", "locator": "內文關於馬士元2026年10月8日說明搜索過程、證人傳訊及勤前教育，並回應未持通知書能否帶走的段落。", "source_id": "src-31", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-9b9874df3d2a" ], "id": "e-src-32", "locator": "內文關於蔣萬安10月31日表示最大程度公開調查報告，以及記者追問公開時程的段落。", "source_id": "src-32", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-e4eeaa0fa128" ], "id": "e-page", "locator": "頁面「還不知道、而且會改變結論的」區段", "source_id": "src-page", "supports": [] } ], "inquiry": { "id": "pursuit_6bbfae2596606c6538c4", "reader_promise": "公布的懲處處理不當發言與督導；以衣著篩選帶回對象，如何符合警方所稱的「證人、自願」，仍須檢驗同行前的選擇。", "root_question": "Commander D宣布將歇業：員警已受懲處，為什麼搜索爭議仍未結束？", "updated_at": "2026-11-04T14:52:37+00:00" }, "queries": [ { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-93f35e1349f4", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-299a5c7dd560", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-cb2de15ee6a8", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ca2e28507226", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ba4444943b00", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-15b647ffc21c", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-78f29c389f1f", "claim-commander-d-search-rights-5f45cd7c0273" ], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-494347ccbef6", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-85dbb9e9e77e", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-cedaa71575c8", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-73bd33af9a96", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-9b9874df3d2a", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-30d52fb2bc98", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-0b4300e845bf", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-442bffe7e45a", "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-e4eeaa0fa128" ] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-e32cfa91dcab", "text": "Commander D宣布將歇業：員警已受懲處，為什麼搜索爭議仍未結束？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-93f35e1349f4" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-93f35e1349f4", "text": "媒體轉載的店家公告說明租約到期、營業至2026年11月8日。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-299a5c7dd560" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-299a5c7dd560", "text": "公開懲處理由對應4名員警的不當發言，以及兩名主管的制止與督導責任。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-cb2de15ee6a8" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-cb2de15ee6a8", "text": "搜索時依法可以禁止在場人員離去，但搜索票本身沒有授權帶走多少人的額度。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ca2e28507226" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-ca2e28507226", "text": "多家報導把被帶回的51名顧客與裸露上身連結；路透社供稿並轉述警方因無法判斷誰涉入而帶回赤膊者。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-ba4444943b00" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-ba4444943b00", "text": "同一批51人見報過涉嫌違反社維法、裁處或送辦，以及證人、自願、未裁罰等不同說法。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-15b647ffc21c" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-15b647ffc21c", "text": "公開線索使我們有理由懷疑，至少部分顧客未獲真正的同行選擇。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-78f29c389f1f" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-78f29c389f1f", "text": "兩份團體聲明要求檢驗執法措施、保存與公開可揭露紀錄、追究責任並改善程序保障。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-commander-d-search-rights-5f45cd7c0273" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-5f45cd7c0273", "text": "英格蘭與威爾斯的官方告知書及Code C，具體說明自願詢問的離開權利，並對涉嫌犯罪者要求告知、確認同意及留下紀錄。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-494347ccbef6" ] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-494347ccbef6", "text": "每名顧客上車時，警方依據的是自由同意，還是具體的合法強制措施？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-85dbb9e9e77e" ] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-85dbb9e9e77e", "text": "行政調查與警政署核復，實際審查了哪些強制措施與同行選擇？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-cedaa71575c8" ] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-cedaa71575c8", "text": "2026年現行警察規範，是否已要求同行前告知可否拒絕並留下紀錄？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-73bd33af9a96" ] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-73bd33af9a96", "text": "51名顧客在各階段的實際身分與裁處結果是什麼？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-9b9874df3d2a" ] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-9b9874df3d2a", "text": "執法指引、權益說明、法律心理支持與紀錄公開承諾，何時落實、內容為何？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-30d52fb2bc98" ] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-30d52fb2bc98", "text": "搜索是否影響店家續租或歇業決定？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-0b4300e845bf" ] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-0b4300e845bf", "text": "條件相近的場所與顧客，是否受到相同查緝及帶回處置？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-442bffe7e45a" ] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-442bffe7e45a", "text": "英格蘭與威爾斯的自願詢問告知與紀錄要求，是否減少強迫或歧視？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-e4eeaa0fa128" ] }, "id": "query-commander-d-search-rights-e4eeaa0fa128", "text": "居民或家屬如何看待本案查緝及處置？" } ], "schema": "walkingbook-public-knowledge-v0", "source": { "path": "docs/product/evidence/walkingbook-question-22ad0c93aad57847-editorial-review.md", "sha256": "a1c0a32c9cf00d1b4d743200f6137e7035162d6ab0528a1b1ca2e73ed0ae6de5" }, "sources": [ { "id": "src-1", "published_at": "2026-11-01", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "停業消息", "url": "https://news.nextapple.com/local/20261101/B8FC711257FEAF2816C528E32C6052C2" }, { "id": "src-2", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "太報", "url": "https://www.taisounds.com/news/content/71/292294" }, { "id": "src-3", "published_at": "2026-10-05", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "懲處報導", "url": "https://www.knews.com.tw/news/71CC0230FF82A1FAC79C0F571F4F2BE9" }, { "id": "src-4", "published_at": "10月20日", "source_type": "民間團體聲明", "title": "10月20日聲明", "url": "https://jrf.org.tw/articles/3323" }, { "id": "src-5", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "刑訴第128條", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawSingle.aspx?flno=128&pcode=C0010001" }, { "id": "src-6", "published_at": "10月29日", "source_type": "政府新聞稿", "title": "市府說明", "url": "https://www.gov.taipei/News_Content.aspx?n=F0DDAF49B89E9413&s=CF00CDC3FDA247BA&sms=72544237BBE4C5F6" }, { "id": "src-7", "published_at": "10月4日", "source_type": "民間團體聯合聲明", "title": "10月4日聲明", "url": "https://www.jrf.org.tw/articles/3319" }, { "id": "src-8", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "刑訴第144條", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawSingle.aspx?flno=144&pcode=C0010001" }, { "id": "src-9", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "聯合報", "url": "https://udn.com/news/story/7315/9793850" }, { "id": "src-10", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "公視", "url": "https://news.pts.org.tw/article/830035" }, { "id": "src-11", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "NOWnews", "url": "https://www.nownews.com/news/6885444" }, { "id": "src-12", "published_at": "", "source_type": "通訊社供稿轉載", "title": "路透社供稿", "url": "https://kfgo.com/2026/10/05/taipei-mayor-defends-citys-inclusivity-after-gay-bar-raid-sparks-protests/" }, { "id": "src-13", "published_at": "2026-10-30", "source_type": "新聞報導（當事人訪談）", "title": "在場者訪談", "url": "https://www.mirrormedia.mg/story/20261030pol001" }, { "id": "src-14", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "社維法第42條", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawSingle.aspx?flno=42&pcode=D0080067" }, { "id": "src-15", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "社維法第41至42、83條", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?PCode=D0080067" }, { "id": "src-16", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "未裁罰說法", "url": "https://www.nownews.com/news/6885779" }, { "id": "src-17", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "通知證人", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawSingle.aspx?flno=196-1&pcode=C0010001" }, { "id": "src-18", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "證人傳票", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawSingle.aspx?flno=175&pcode=C0010001" }, { "id": "src-19", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "不到場的處理", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawSingle.aspx?flno=178&pcode=C0010001" }, { "id": "src-20", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "刑訴第95條", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawSingle.aspx?flno=95&pcode=C0010001" }, { "id": "src-21", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "處理辦法第27條", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=D0080070" }, { "id": "src-22", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "錄音保管辦法", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=I0030061" }, { "id": "src-23", "published_at": "2024", "source_type": "政府書面報告", "title": "警政署書面報告，頁1至2", "url": "https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/SittingAttachment/download/2024101729/11021337042002060002.pdf" }, { "id": "src-24", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府權利告知書", "title": "官方告知書", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/voluntary-police-interview-your-rights/remember-your-rights-voluntary-interview-accessible-version" }, { "id": "src-25", "published_at": "", "source_type": "官方作業守則", "title": "Code C第3.21至3.22B", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/pace-code-c-2023/pace-code-c-2023-accessible" }, { "id": "src-26", "published_at": "", "source_type": "官方統計報告", "title": "官方統計第5.5.1節", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/other-pace-powers-year-ending-march-2023/police-powers-and-procedures-other-pace-powers-england-and-wales-year-ending-31-march-2023" }, { "id": "src-27", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導（刊載警方書面回應）", "title": "警方回應", "url": "https://www.nownews.com/news/6887222" }, { "id": "src-28", "published_at": "", "source_type": "官方開放資料集", "title": "官方資料集", "url": "https://data.taipei/dataset/detail?id=08a489de-b4d8-406b-b4bf-fb30ce7b6af4" }, { "id": "src-29", "published_at": "2026-10-05", "source_type": "議員書面質詢", "title": "書面質詢", "url": "https://gaz.tcc.gov.tw/s/file/D5F18FCFA661B3783D75AF8EF72C0E35731CDCEB21783E8C7FA3482A987E1BA1D8C9AC3417A606F00513BAA6A2C5A5F133A8965ED2D182C6/9BAA481A4AEA27116808C548CFA62FBB" }, { "id": "src-30", "published_at": "2026-09-11", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "質詢當日報導", "url": "https://www.nownews.com/news/6874284" }, { "id": "src-31", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "次長說明", "url": "https://www.nownews.com/news/6881813" }, { "id": "src-32", "published_at": "", "source_type": "通訊社新聞報導", "title": "中央社", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aloc/202610310162.aspx" }, { "id": "src-page", "published_at": "", "source_type": "walkingbook_public_page", "title": "Commander D宣布將歇業：員警已受懲處，為什麼搜索爭議仍未結束？", "url": "https://walkingbook.tw/inquiry/commander-d-search-rights/" } ], "unknowns": [ { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "取得去識別化的逐類帶回依據、身分與告知紀錄，並有出發前影音或同意紀錄可交叉核對。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-11", "e-src-13", "e-src-14", "e-src-16" ], "id": "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-494347ccbef6", "question": "每名顧客上車時，警方依據的是自由同意，還是具體的合法強制措施？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "市府、北市警局及警政署公開去識別化調查與核復內容，足以辨認審查項目、認定依據及結論。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-6" ], "id": "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-85dbb9e9e77e", "question": "行政調查與警政署核復，實際審查了哪些強制措施與同行選擇？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "取得115年新版警察偵查犯罪手冊相關附件及有效版本依據，確認證人、嫌疑人同行前的適用條文。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-23" ], "id": "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-cedaa71575c8", "question": "2026年現行警察規範，是否已要求同行前告知可否拒絕並留下紀錄？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "取得去識別化筆錄身分、身分轉換依據及裁處彙整，能對應同一批51人且不暴露個資。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-3", "e-src-13", "e-src-16" ], "id": "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-73bd33af9a96", "question": "51名顧客在各階段的實際身分與裁處結果是什麼？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "公布定稿指引、施行日期與支持措施，並提供紀錄公開範圍及議會改善報告的具體答覆。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-6", "e-src-16", "e-src-29", "e-src-32" ], "id": "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-9b9874df3d2a", "question": "執法指引、權益說明、法律心理支持與紀錄公開承諾，何時落實、內容為何？", "status": "world_pending" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "出現公開租約文件或可核實的當事方說明，具體交代續租決策與搜索的關係。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-1" ], "id": "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-30d52fb2bc98", "question": "搜索是否影響店家續租或歇業決定？", "status": "bounded_unknown" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "取得含相近風險、檢舉線索、現場行為與顧客處置的可比去識別資料，而非僅有機關件數。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-27", "e-src-28" ], "id": "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-0b4300e845bf", "question": "條件相近的場所與顧客，是否受到相同查緝及帶回處置？", "status": "bounded_unknown" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "取得直接評估相關要求實施效果的研究，並能處理漏記、重複與比較條件。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-24", "e-src-25", "e-src-26" ], "id": "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-442bffe7e45a", "question": "英格蘭與威爾斯的自願詢問告知與紀錄要求，是否減少強迫或歧視？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "出現可核實的公開直接陳述，足以區分對調查必要性與具體執法措施的意見。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-page" ], "id": "unknown-commander-d-search-rights-e4eeaa0fa128", "question": "居民或家屬如何看待本案查緝及處置？", "status": "public_not_found" } ] }