{ "claims": [ { "boundary": "不起訴理由來自媒體與人本轉述，處分書全文未公開；不能推論檢方看過哪些研究倫理材料。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-3", "e-src-4", "e-src-5" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-8127cbab0525", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣", "population": "臺師大女足隊參與陳、周相關研究的隊員", "time": "2025-09-16 至 2026-09-30" }, "status": "supported", "text": "國科會認定 6 件計畫違失，理由包括參與者「被脅迫參與研究」與未揭露教練兼共同主持人的權力不對等；檢方認為沒有足夠證據證明教練明示或暗示不參加會有不利後果，強制罪不起訴。兩者回答不同問題，不互相推翻。" }, { "boundary": "屬媒體與人本對不起訴處分書的轉述，不是檢方新聞稿原文。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-4", "e-src-73" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-aa043b72375f", "scope": { "geography": "臺北地檢署轄區", "population": "周台英強制罪嫌部分", "time": "2026-09-30" }, "status": "supported", "text": "據報導，檢方認為教練能評定專長學分、與學生權力不對等，要求參加實驗「或有不當」，並把霸凌與研究倫理判斷交回權責機關。" }, { "boundary": "學校承認的是大方向，每項研究抽了幾次、誰抽血沒有官方逐項確認；檢方查到多數抽血由護理師執行，兩者矛盾未解。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-2", "e-src-23" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-72f6bb7edcc9", "scope": { "geography": "臺師大", "population": "臺師大女足隊受試者", "time": "2024-11-28 至 2025-07-15" }, "status": "supported", "text": "臺師大 2024-11 說學生事先同意、抽血者都有醫事資格；2025-07-15 自己承認有同意書補簽、受試費繳回當隊費、非護理人員抽血與霸凌。" }, { "boundary": "各數字期間與計算範圍不同，不能相減推論差額被誰拿走。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-3", "e-src-14", "e-src-15" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82592956e379", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣", "population": "臺師大女足隊受試者", "time": "2019–2024 年計畫；2025-08 至 2026-09 文件" }, "status": "supported", "text": "受試費至少有 138 萬餘元（監察院糾正）、129 萬 3000 元（北檢起訴）、122 萬餘元（臺師大代墊返還 26 人）三個總額，沒有任何機關公開對帳。" }, { "boundary": "只能說公開資料中找不到補償機制；運動部內部是否研議不得而知，原函附件與申訴窗口頁面打不開。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-14", "e-src-26", "e-src-27" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-850099c6ccce", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣", "population": "前體育署運科計畫受試選手（含部分女足隊員）", "time": "2025-08-30 至 2026-10-11" }, "status": "supported", "text": "體育署 2025-08-30 承諾「將究責並補償選手」、研擬補償機制；運動部後來公開的處置文件只有不追溯送審、學校調查金流、申訴窗口與參與者保護，沒有提到補償，也沒有說明原因。" }, { "boundary": "不能說這些計畫都抽血或都傷害受試者，也不能推到國科會或其他大學研究。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-14", "e-src-53" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-118261511106", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣", "population": "前體育署運科支援與輔助計畫中涉及未成年人者", "time": "2017–2025（106–114 年度）" }, "status": "supported", "text": "前體育署補助、涉及未成年人的 199 件運科計畫中，162 件未送研究倫理審查、116 件未取得本人或法定代理人同意；監察院 2026-07 指出教育部仍未完成通盤查處。" }, { "boundary": "上一版誤寫生效日查不到；本項不能推論國科會申請書或合約書完全沒有相關欄位，因為那部分只讀到二手副本。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-76", "e-src-77" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-58b0b3547279", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣", "population": "國科會補助的研究計畫", "time": "2026-02-06 至 2026-04-10" }, "status": "corrected", "text": "國科會 2026-02-06 修正生效學術倫理審議要點，2026-04-10 要求凡從事人體研究都附倫理核准文件；這些修正對準文件與處罰，沒有要求揭露教練或指導關係。" }, { "boundary": "只描述草案條文與議事頁進度，不能推論委員會不會排審。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-74", "e-src-75" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-95228d4c5197", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣立法院", "population": "人體研究法修正", "time": "2026-04-22 至 2026-10-11" }, "status": "supported", "text": "17 位立委的人體研究法修正草案寫到師大女足案的權力關係，但只把「得拒絕、不受不利對待」加進告知事項，採檢者執照只要求載明、沒有罰則；2026-05-05 交付委員會後沒有審查紀錄。" }, { "boundary": "不能說教育部沒有查核，只能說評估意見不再公開。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-78", "e-src-79", "e-src-80" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-156cc091b6fc", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣", "population": "各校人體研究倫理審查會", "time": "2025-06-18 舊版至 2026-09-02 新版" }, "status": "supported", "text": "教育部 2026-08/09 修正查核要點，可暫停審查會收新案並新增「研究對象保護之嚴謹性」，但把查核結果（包括意見）公告改成只公告名單、評估意見函送審查會。" }, { "boundary": "函釋內容來自草案引述與醫院轉貼；只能說公開資料中找不到，不能說衛福部內部沒有研議。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-4", "e-src-12", "e-src-14", "e-src-74" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82db15492e23", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣", "population": "人體研究法主管機關", "time": "2025-08 至 2026-10-11" }, "status": "partially_supported", "text": "衛福部 2025-08 函釋說研究抽血也應由有執照醫事人員執行，但違反時沒有罰則接得住；監察院 2026-07 請它檢討人體研究法後，到 2026-10-11 公開資料中找不到它的修法草案或回應。" }, { "boundary": "把握程度為很可能；若衛福部已有未公開草案或運動部保護規範明文要求由教練以外的人取得同意，判斷要改。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-69", "e-src-74", "e-src-75", "e-src-76", "e-src-77", "e-src-78" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-547bb707071d", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣", "population": "教練兼研究者的運動員研究受試者", "time": "至 2026-10-11" }, "status": "synthesis", "text": "教練同時是研究者時學生能不能說不，到 2026-10-11 沒有任何機關以規則補上；補上的多半是讓沒送審、文件造假更容易被抓、罰得更重的部分。" }, { "boundary": "只代表出面的學生，不能推論所有受害者都不要錢；節目錄於 2025-07，不能用來評價後來的道歉與全台專案。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-20", "e-src-21", "e-src-66" ], "id": "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-9e26b1e9c290", "scope": { "geography": "臺灣", "population": "當年出面揭露的前隊員", "time": "2025-07" }, "status": "supported", "text": "出面的前隊員說她要的是承認與道歉、錢「於事無補」，但也說受害者訴求不同，有人要學籍、有人要輔導、有人只要道歉。" } ], "evidence": [ { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-1", "locator": "正文第 2 段", "source_id": "src-1", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-2", "locator": "正文第 4、5 段", "source_id": "src-2", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-72f6bb7edcc9" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-48813eb1f49d", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-bd18bf73c21c" ], "id": "e-src-3", "locator": "全文（起訴金額、被控內容、抽血執行者）", "source_id": "src-3", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-8127cbab0525", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82592956e379" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-abba0e73780a" ], "id": "e-src-4", "locator": "不起訴理由段落（強制罪、醫師法、或有不當）", "source_id": "src-4", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-8127cbab0525", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82db15492e23", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-aa043b72375f" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-454edb4fdf4c" ], "id": "e-src-5", "locator": "壹、一（二）違失理由；三（一）至（四）處分；參、強化措施", "source_id": "src-5", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-8127cbab0525" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-6", "locator": "偵查經過、起訴內容與相關新聞摘要（人本呼籲修法）", "source_id": "src-6", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-7", "locator": "隊員偵查證詞段落", "source_id": "src-7", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-8", "locator": "第 304 條", "source_id": "src-8", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-9", "locator": "強制罪要件說明", "source_id": "src-9", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-10", "locator": "Article 3.1 Application", "source_id": "src-10", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-11", "locator": "同意為動態過程段落", "source_id": "src-11", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-1559ee0e66c7" ], "id": "e-src-12", "locator": "第 5、14、22 條；修正日期 2019-01-02", "source_id": "src-12", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82db15492e23" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-13", "locator": "易受傷害族群定義說明", "source_id": "src-13", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-1559ee0e66c7", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-454edb4fdf4c", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-6e0cf8dd89f6", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-b21b929af394", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-bd18bf73c21c" ], "id": "e-src-14", "locator": "公布版 p.2、p.6–8、p.12–24", "source_id": "src-14", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-118261511106", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82592956e379", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82db15492e23", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-850099c6ccce" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-bd18bf73c21c" ], "id": "e-src-15", "locator": "糾正案文（流於形式、監管不彰、回繳 138 萬餘元）", "source_id": "src-15", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82592956e379" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-16", "locator": "節目簡介", "source_id": "src-16", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-17", "locator": "教育部會面學生段落", "source_id": "src-17", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-18", "locator": "開頭兩段及第 1 至 6 條", "source_id": "src-18", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-19", "locator": "人本轉述前隊員聲明段落", "source_id": "src-19", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-20", "locator": "受訪段落", "source_id": "src-20", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-9e26b1e9c290" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-21", "locator": "受害學生受訪段落", "source_id": "src-21", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-9e26b1e9c290" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-22", "locator": "p.1", "source_id": "src-22", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-23", "locator": "正文第 3 段", "source_id": "src-23", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-72f6bb7edcc9" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-24", "locator": "學生受訪段落", "source_id": "src-24", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-25", "locator": "全文", "source_id": "src-25", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-6e0cf8dd89f6" ], "id": "e-src-26", "locator": "全文（上版日期 114-08-30）", "source_id": "src-26", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-850099c6ccce" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-6e0cf8dd89f6", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-b21b929af394" ], "id": "e-src-27", "locator": "公告內文一至五點", "source_id": "src-27", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-850099c6ccce" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-28", "locator": "p.1–2", "source_id": "src-28", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-29", "locator": "前隊員受訪段落", "source_id": "src-29", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-a3f0cda5fca9" ], "id": "e-src-30", "locator": "專案公告全文", "source_id": "src-30", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-a3f0cda5fca9" ], "id": "e-src-31", "locator": "p.1–3", "source_id": "src-31", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-32", "locator": "全文", "source_id": "src-32", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-f3e90ac46f44" ], "id": "e-src-33", "locator": "印刷頁 5、8", "source_id": "src-33", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-34", "locator": "首頁法規區（申訴處理標準作業程序）", "source_id": "src-34", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-35", "locator": "全文", "source_id": "src-35", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-36", "locator": "全文", "source_id": "src-36", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-37", "locator": "行動計畫頁", "source_id": "src-37", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-38", "locator": "進度報告全文", "source_id": "src-38", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-39", "locator": "資格條件段落", "source_id": "src-39", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-40", "locator": "§46.116(b)(6)", "source_id": "src-40", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-48813eb1f49d" ], "id": "e-src-41", "locator": "北檢說明與人本發言段落", "source_id": "src-41", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-42", "locator": "再議期限說明", "source_id": "src-42", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-43", "locator": "正文第 2 段", "source_id": "src-43", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-44", "locator": "全文", "source_id": "src-44", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-623f1068d85f" ], "id": "e-src-45", "locator": "正文第 5–7、10 段", "source_id": "src-45", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-46", "locator": "p.5", "source_id": "src-46", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-623f1068d85f" ], "id": "e-src-47", "locator": "臺師大回應段落", "source_id": "src-47", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-f3e90ac46f44" ], "id": "e-src-48", "locator": "正文一、二、四", "source_id": "src-48", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-49", "locator": "處分公告", "source_id": "src-49", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-50", "locator": "申訴委員會說明", "source_id": "src-50", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-51", "locator": "列表最新一筆 2026-04-23（查至 2026-09-30）", "source_id": "src-51", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-52", "locator": "第 1–5 段", "source_id": "src-52", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-53", "locator": "正文第 2–4 段", "source_id": "src-53", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-118261511106" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-54", "locator": "§46.116(a)(2)", "source_id": "src-54", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-55", "locator": "全文", "source_id": "src-55", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-56", "locator": "FAQ", "source_id": "src-56", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-57", "locator": "服務說明", "source_id": "src-57", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-58", "locator": "全文", "source_id": "src-58", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-59", "locator": "記者會段落", "source_id": "src-59", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-60", "locator": "工會聲明段落（未經證實）", "source_id": "src-60", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-61", "locator": "網友留言（未經證實）", "source_id": "src-61", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-62", "locator": "投書全文（未經證實）", "source_id": "src-62", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-63", "locator": "正文第 5–7 段", "source_id": "src-63", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-abba0e73780a" ], "id": "e-src-64", "locator": "列表第 1 頁（查至 115-10-05）", "source_id": "src-64", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-65", "locator": "中央社新聞轉貼", "source_id": "src-65", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-66", "locator": "節目方手動中文字幕（逐句核對）", "source_id": "src-66", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-9e26b1e9c290" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-a3f0cda5fca9" ], "id": "e-src-67", "locator": "第 1 頁（最新一則 2026-09-22）", "source_id": "src-67", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-b21b929af394" ], "id": "e-src-68", "locator": "印刷頁 p.132–134（教育及文化委員會 2026-04-09）", "source_id": "src-68", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-b21b929af394" ], "id": "e-src-69", "locator": "發布令及第三、七、十四、十五點", "source_id": "src-69", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-547bb707071d" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-70", "locator": "首段、撤回條款、是否滿 18 歲欄", "source_id": "src-70", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-71", "locator": "倫理委員會說明", "source_id": "src-71", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-72", "locator": "§6.1", "source_id": "src-72", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-abba0e73780a" ], "id": "e-src-73", "locator": "引述不起訴書與起訴書段落；三項要求", "source_id": "src-73", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-aa043b72375f" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-1559ee0e66c7", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-78016dd61dfc" ], "id": "e-src-74", "locator": "p.1 案由；p.2 第 6 條與衛福部函釋引述；p.4–5 第 14 條及說明二", "source_id": "src-74", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-547bb707071d", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82db15492e23", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-95228d4c5197" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-1559ee0e66c7", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-78016dd61dfc" ], "id": "e-src-75", "locator": "審議進度（最後一筆 2026-05-05 交付審查）", "source_id": "src-75", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-547bb707071d", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-95228d4c5197" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-76", "locator": "第十一點第四項、第十三點第四項", "source_id": "src-76", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-547bb707071d", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-58b0b3547279" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-77", "locator": "修正資訊、第 3、13、13 之一、17、18 點", "source_id": "src-77", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-547bb707071d", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-58b0b3547279" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-623f1068d85f" ], "id": "e-src-78", "locator": "第四點、第六點第三款", "source_id": "src-78", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-156cc091b6fc", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-547bb707071d" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-79", "locator": "2025-06-18 版第六點第三款", "source_id": "src-79", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-156cc091b6fc" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-80", "locator": "第七點第六款", "source_id": "src-80", "supports": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-156cc091b6fc" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-81", "locator": "前言、修法重點（一）（三）", "source_id": "src-81", "supports": [] } ], "inquiry": { "id": "pursuit_121776c9d2fcc2b7d1cc", "reader_promise": "強制罪不起訴，不代表當年沒有被逼。教練同時是研究者時學生能不能說不，到 2026 年 10 月 11 日仍沒有任何機關補上；有人在補洞，但補的多半是「抓得到、罰得重」那一半。", "root_question": "師大女足案，後來怎麼了？", "updated_at": "2026-10-10T20:47:03+00:00" }, "queries": [ { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-8127cbab0525", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-aa043b72375f", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-72f6bb7edcc9", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82592956e379", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-850099c6ccce", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-118261511106", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-58b0b3547279", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-95228d4c5197", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-156cc091b6fc", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82db15492e23", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-547bb707071d", "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-9e26b1e9c290" ], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-abba0e73780a", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-454edb4fdf4c", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-f3e90ac46f44", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-bd18bf73c21c", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-a3f0cda5fca9", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-6e0cf8dd89f6", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-1559ee0e66c7", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-78016dd61dfc", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-b21b929af394", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-623f1068d85f", "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-48813eb1f49d" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-3bdc86888b64", "text": "師大女足案，後來怎麼了？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-8127cbab0525" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-8127cbab0525", "text": "國科會認定 6 件計畫違失，理由包括參與者「被脅迫參與研究」與未揭露教練兼共同主持人的權力不對等；檢方認為沒有足夠證據證明教練明示或暗示不參加會有不利後果，強制罪不起訴。兩者回答不同問題，不互相推翻。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-aa043b72375f" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-aa043b72375f", "text": "據報導，檢方認為教練能評定專長學分、與學生權力不對等，要求參加實驗「或有不當」，並把霸凌與研究倫理判斷交回權責機關。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-72f6bb7edcc9" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-72f6bb7edcc9", "text": "臺師大 2024-11 說學生事先同意、抽血者都有醫事資格；2025-07-15 自己承認有同意書補簽、受試費繳回當隊費、非護理人員抽血與霸凌。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82592956e379" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82592956e379", "text": "受試費至少有 138 萬餘元（監察院糾正）、129 萬 3000 元（北檢起訴）、122 萬餘元（臺師大代墊返還 26 人）三個總額，沒有任何機關公開對帳。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-850099c6ccce" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-850099c6ccce", "text": "體育署 2025-08-30 承諾「將究責並補償選手」、研擬補償機制；運動部後來公開的處置文件只有不追溯送審、學校調查金流、申訴窗口與參與者保護，沒有提到補償，也沒有說明原因。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-118261511106" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-118261511106", "text": "前體育署補助、涉及未成年人的 199 件運科計畫中，162 件未送研究倫理審查、116 件未取得本人或法定代理人同意；監察院 2026-07 指出教育部仍未完成通盤查處。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-58b0b3547279" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-58b0b3547279", "text": "國科會 2026-02-06 修正生效學術倫理審議要點，2026-04-10 要求凡從事人體研究都附倫理核准文件；這些修正對準文件與處罰，沒有要求揭露教練或指導關係。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-95228d4c5197" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-95228d4c5197", "text": "17 位立委的人體研究法修正草案寫到師大女足案的權力關係，但只把「得拒絕、不受不利對待」加進告知事項，採檢者執照只要求載明、沒有罰則；2026-05-05 交付委員會後沒有審查紀錄。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-156cc091b6fc" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-156cc091b6fc", "text": "教育部 2026-08/09 修正查核要點，可暫停審查會收新案並新增「研究對象保護之嚴謹性」，但把查核結果（包括意見）公告改成只公告名單、評估意見函送審查會。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82db15492e23" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-82db15492e23", "text": "衛福部 2025-08 函釋說研究抽血也應由有執照醫事人員執行，但違反時沒有罰則接得住；監察院 2026-07 請它檢討人體研究法後，到 2026-10-11 公開資料中找不到它的修法草案或回應。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-547bb707071d" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-547bb707071d", "text": "教練同時是研究者時學生能不能說不，到 2026-10-11 沒有任何機關以規則補上；補上的多半是讓沒送審、文件造假更容易被抓、罰得更重的部分。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-9e26b1e9c290" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-9e26b1e9c290", "text": "出面的前隊員說她要的是承認與道歉、錢「於事無補」，但也說受害者訴求不同，有人要學籍、有人要輔導、有人只要道歉。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-abba0e73780a" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-abba0e73780a", "text": "起訴書與不起訴處分書全文寫了什麼？檢方有沒有調閱國科會與教育部的研究倫理調查材料？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-454edb4fdf4c" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-454edb4fdf4c", "text": "國科會與教育部逐案調查中，每項研究抽了幾次、同意書何時簽、誰抽的血？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-f3e90ac46f44" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-f3e90ac46f44", "text": "23 校 97 件含血液樣本研究的查核結果是什麼？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-bd18bf73c21c" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-bd18bf73c21c", "text": "138 萬、129.3 萬、122 萬三個受試費總額差在哪裡？學生有沒有拿回全部？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-a3f0cda5fca9" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-a3f0cda5fca9", "text": "諮商專案與申訴窗口有多少人使用？2026 年 6 月底後有沒有延長？法律協助與復學說明幫了幾個人？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-6e0cf8dd89f6" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-6e0cf8dd89f6", "text": "運動部有沒有退費以外的補償機制？申訴窗口受理了什麼、收過幾件？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-1559ee0e66c7" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-1559ee0e66c7", "text": "衛福部對人體研究法有沒有修法研議？它怎麼回覆監察院 2026 年 7 月的要求與北檢的函詢？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-78016dd61dfc" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-78016dd61dfc", "text": "立委人體研究法草案會不會排審？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-b21b929af394" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-b21b929af394", "text": "運動部承諾的運科作業指引、參與者保護規範，以及運科中心保護委員會的設置規定與審查紀錄是什麼？289 件逐案清查表與女足案內部調查結論為何？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-623f1068d85f" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-623f1068d85f", "text": "臺師大 IRB 是否已恢復收案？陳忠慶停聘是否已核定？教育部各校查核評估意見如何？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-48813eb1f49d" ] }, "id": "query-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-48813eb1f49d", "text": "周台英的刑事案件，法院會怎麼判？" } ], "schema": "walkingbook-public-knowledge-v0", "source": { "path": "docs/product/evidence/walkingbook-question-5c04d601a4d48c8b-editorial-review.md", "sha256": "af55282a10a2b5c6db9726b0b816fbc828f5e533262d15604ea0163a5d756a4b" }, "sources": [ { "id": "src-1", "published_at": "2024-11-28", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "聯合報：立委揭露女足抽血", "url": "https://udn.com/news/story/6928/8390031" }, { "id": "src-2", "published_at": "2024-11-28", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社：臺師大當日回應", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/ahel/202411280359.aspx" }, { "id": "src-3", "published_at": "2026-09-30", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社：北檢偵結", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/asoc/202609300069.aspx" }, { "id": "src-4", "published_at": "2026-09-30", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "自由時報：不起訴理由", "url": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/society/breakingnews/5590738" }, { "id": "src-5", "published_at": "2025-09-16", "source_type": "政府公告", "title": "國科會處分公告", "url": "https://www.nstc.gov.tw/folksonomy/detail/4a511349-dfb8-481b-8a18-fa912f442f5c?l=ch" }, { "id": "src-6", "published_at": "2026-09-30", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "聯合報：偵結報導", "url": "https://udn.com/news/story/7321/9785051" }, { "id": "src-7", "published_at": "2026-09-30", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "壹蘋：隊員證詞", "url": "https://news.nextapple.com/local/20260930/4F2BE815AE939FAB37C9C467FF691338" }, { "id": "src-8", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "刑法第304條", "url": "https://mojlaw.moj.gov.tw/LawContentExtent.aspx?LSID=FL001424&LawNo=304&media=print" }, { "id": "src-9", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府說明", "title": "高檢署說明", "url": "https://www.tph.moj.gov.tw/4421/4475/632364/1375799/post" }, { "id": "src-10", "published_at": "2022", "source_type": "國外政策", "title": "加拿大 TCPS2 第 3 章", "url": "https://ethics.gc.ca/eng/tcps2-eptc2_2022_chapter3-chapitre3.html" }, { "id": "src-11", "published_at": "", "source_type": "評論", "title": "科學月刊", "url": "https://www.scimonth.com.tw/archives/13525" }, { "id": "src-12", "published_at": "2019-01-02", "source_type": "法規", "title": "人體研究法", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=L0020176" }, { "id": "src-13", "published_at": "", "source_type": "專業機構說明", "title": "臺大醫院倫理中心", "url": "https://www.ntuh.gov.tw/RECO/FormData%21detail.action?af=167787" }, { "id": "src-14", "published_at": "2026-07-29", "source_type": "監察院調查報告", "title": "監察院 115教調31 調查報告", "url": "https://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=133&s=49744" }, { "id": "src-15", "published_at": "2025-09-11", "source_type": "監察院糾正案", "title": "監察院糾正案", "url": "https://www.cy.gov.tw/CyBsBoxContent.aspx?n=134&s=49306" }, { "id": "src-16", "published_at": "2025-07-22", "source_type": "Podcast（利益揭露：本刊節目）", "title": "Apple Podcasts：只能喝酒的圖書館 EP112", "url": "https://podcasts.apple.com/jp/podcast/id1533685480?i=1000718365911" }, { "id": "src-17", "published_at": "2025-07-18", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "端傳媒", "url": "https://theinitium.com/20250718-whatsnew-taiwan-ntnu-women-soccer-blood-draw/" }, { "id": "src-18", "published_at": "2025-07-18", "source_type": "學校聲明", "title": "臺師大道歉聲明", "url": "https://pr.ntnu.edu.tw/news/index.php?id=23675&mode=data" }, { "id": "src-19", "published_at": "2025-07-19", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社：校長鞠躬道歉", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/ahel/202507190138.aspx" }, { "id": "src-20", "published_at": "2025-07-16", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "台視：前隊員受訪", "url": "https://news.ttv.com.tw/news/11407160004500W" }, { "id": "src-21", "published_at": "2025-07-17", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "今周刊：休學學生", "url": "https://www.businesstoday.com.tw/article/category/183035/post/202507170028/" }, { "id": "src-22", "published_at": "2025-07-28", "source_type": "學校公告", "title": "臺師大受試者費用返還公告", "url": "https://www.sa.ntnu.edu.tw/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/%E5%A5%B3%E8%B6%B3%E8%A8%88%E7%95%AB%E5%8F%97%E8%A9%A6%E8%80%85%E8%B2%BB%E7%94%A8%E8%BF%94%E9%82%84%E5%85%AC%E5%91%8A.pdf" }, { "id": "src-23", "published_at": "2025-07-15", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社：臺師大承認補簽等情形", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/ahel/202507150276.aspx" }, { "id": "src-24", "published_at": "2025-07-18", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "華視：學生說沒拿到", "url": "https://news.cts.com.tw/cts/general/202507/202507182493748.html" }, { "id": "src-25", "published_at": "2026-09-30", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社：臺師大偵結回應", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/ahel/202609300095.aspx" }, { "id": "src-26", "published_at": "2025-08-30", "source_type": "政府聲明", "title": "體育署聲明：將究責並補償選手", "url": "https://www.edu.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=9E7AC85F1954DDA8&s=74B3AC9C4B732BE1" }, { "id": "src-27", "published_at": "2026-01-08", "source_type": "轉發政府函", "title": "臺北市立大學轉發運動部函", "url": "https://research1.utaipei.edu.tw/p/405-1005-129480,c3305.php?Lang=zh-tw" }, { "id": "src-28", "published_at": "2026-07-16", "source_type": "監察院文件", "title": "監察院糾正案結案情形表", "url": "https://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/76788" }, { "id": "src-29", "published_at": "2025-07-16", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "知新聞：諮商不實用", "url": "https://www.knews.com.tw/news/C50AB3EBF5A0A3EC1452F9E3D5232ECD" }, { "id": "src-30", "published_at": "2025-08-29", "source_type": "專業團體公告", "title": "諮商心理師公會全聯會公告", "url": "https://www.tcpu.org.tw/news/2025-08-29-03-23-49.html" }, { "id": "src-31", "published_at": "2025-08", "source_type": "學校計畫", "title": "臺師大女足專案輔導計畫", "url": "https://www.sa.ntnu.edu.tw/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/%E5%A5%B3%E5%AD%90%E8%B6%B3%E7%90%83%E9%9A%8A%E5%B0%88%E6%A1%88%E8%BC%94%E5%B0%8E%E8%A8%88%E7%95%AB%E8%AA%AA%E6%98%8E%E8%88%87%E5%9F%B7%E8%A1%8C.pdf" }, { "id": "src-32", "published_at": "2026-09-30", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社：吹哨者盼改變體育環境", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/ahel/202609300281.aspx" }, { "id": "src-33", "published_at": "2025-08-07", "source_type": "立法院報告", "title": "國科會向立法院書面報告", "url": "https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/SittingAttachment/download/2025073105/00875024302202061002.pdf" }, { "id": "src-34", "published_at": "", "source_type": "學校網站", "title": "臺師大研究參與者保護辦公室", "url": "https://www.ohsp.ntnu.edu.tw/" }, { "id": "src-35", "published_at": "2022-08-10", "source_type": "國外新聞", "title": "ABC：澳洲體操修復式對話", "url": "https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-08-10/former-gymnasts-asked-to-sign-nda-abuse-reconciliation-meeting/101316032" }, { "id": "src-36", "published_at": "2022", "source_type": "國外新聞", "title": "BBC：英國體操道歉", "url": "https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/gymnastics/61796129" }, { "id": "src-37", "published_at": "", "source_type": "國外組織文件", "title": "British Gymnastics Reform 25 行動計畫", "url": "https://www.british-gymnastics.org/reform-25-action-plan" }, { "id": "src-38", "published_at": "2023", "source_type": "國外組織文件", "title": "British Gymnastics 進度報告", "url": "https://www.british-gymnastics.org/articles/reform-25-our-progress-and-learnings" }, { "id": "src-39", "published_at": "", "source_type": "國外制度", "title": "Sport Integrity Canada 心理服務", "url": "https://sportintegrity.ca/mental-health-services-program" }, { "id": "src-40", "published_at": "", "source_type": "國外法規", "title": "45 CFR 46.116(b)(6)", "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-45/subtitle-A/subchapter-A/part-46#p-46.116(b)(6)" }, { "id": "src-41", "published_at": "2026-09-30", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "公視：偵結報導", "url": "https://news.pts.org.tw/article/829358" }, { "id": "src-42", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府說明", "title": "北檢：再議說明", "url": "https://www.tpc.moj.gov.tw/292885/974636/975686/975712/post" }, { "id": "src-43", "published_at": "2025-07-16", "source_type": "政府公告", "title": "教育部：霸凌成立公告", "url": "https://www.moe.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=9E7AC85F1954DDA8&s=64F66AA17C8FCA73" }, { "id": "src-44", "published_at": "2025-07-25", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社：周台英解聘", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/ahel/202507250114.aspx" }, { "id": "src-45", "published_at": "2026-03-04", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社：陳忠慶停聘補正未完成", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/ahel/202603040104.aspx" }, { "id": "src-46", "published_at": "2025-07", "source_type": "立法院報告", "title": "教育部向立法院報告", "url": "https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/SittingAttachment/download/2025071857/02270002208512250003.pdf" }, { "id": "src-47", "published_at": "2026-07-01", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "知新聞：IRB 仍待恢復", "url": "https://www.knews.com.tw/news/E37AA0F44BAC30AC7703545A271AA0EA" }, { "id": "src-48", "published_at": "2025-08-19", "source_type": "政府公告", "title": "教育部：跨部會專案小組清查", "url": "https://www.edu.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=9E7AC85F1954DDA8&s=7F8D4D01AE7EDC39&sms=169B8E91BB75571F" }, { "id": "src-49", "published_at": "2025-07-28", "source_type": "協會公告", "title": "足協紀律處分", "url": "https://www.ctfa.com.tw/latest-news/ctfa-announcement/disciplinary-decision/7843-1140728.html" }, { "id": "src-50", "published_at": "", "source_type": "協會公告", "title": "足協申訴委員會", "url": "https://www.ctfa.com.tw/index.php?Itemid=7279&id=8091&option=com_content&view=article" }, { "id": "src-51", "published_at": "", "source_type": "協會公告列表", "title": "足協紀律處分公告列表", "url": "https://www.ctfa.com.tw/latest-news/ctfa-announcement/disciplinary-decision.html" }, { "id": "src-52", "published_at": "2026-04-21", "source_type": "政府新聞稿", "title": "教育部：運動競技學系另案", "url": "https://www.moe.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=9E7AC85F1954DDA8&s=1390E5E87C2F85DC&sms=169B8E91BB75571F" }, { "id": "src-53", "published_at": "2026-07-31", "source_type": "監察院新聞稿", "title": "監察院第二輪調查新聞稿", "url": "https://www.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=124&s=37800" }, { "id": "src-54", "published_at": "", "source_type": "國外法規", "title": "45 CFR 46.116", "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-45/subtitle-A/subchapter-A/part-46/subpart-A/section-46.116" }, { "id": "src-55", "published_at": "", "source_type": "國外大學規範", "title": "康乃狄克大學 IRB 學生運動員指引", "url": "https://ovpr.uconn.edu/services/rics/irb/researcher-guide/student-athletes/" }, { "id": "src-56", "published_at": "", "source_type": "國外組織", "title": "SafeSport FAQ", "url": "https://uscenterforsafesport.org/about/faqs/" }, { "id": "src-57", "published_at": "", "source_type": "國外組織", "title": "Sport Integrity（Sport Resolutions）", "url": "https://www.sportresolutions.com/services/sport-integrity" }, { "id": "src-58", "published_at": "2025-08-26", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "公視：陳忠慶證人約談", "url": "https://news.pts.org.tw/article/767371" }, { "id": "src-59", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "鏡報：學分是抽血換來的", "url": "https://www.mirrordaily.news/story/88728" }, { "id": "src-60", "published_at": "2025-07-20", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "民視：女子足球員工會聲明", "url": "https://health.ftvnews.com.tw/news/detail/2025720W0392" }, { "id": "src-61", "published_at": "2025-07-15", "source_type": "社群貼文", "title": "PTT 鏡像", "url": "https://www.pttweb.cc/bbs/BaseballXXXX/M.1752594889.A.11B" }, { "id": "src-62", "published_at": "2025-07-17", "source_type": "投書", "title": "民視論壇：律師投書", "url": "https://health.ftvnews.com.tw/news/detail/2025717W0256" }, { "id": "src-64", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府網站列表", "title": "北檢新聞稿列表", "url": "https://www.tpc.moj.gov.tw/292885/293089/293092/?Page=1&PageSize=40&type=" }, { "id": "src-65", "published_at": "", "source_type": "社群貼文", "title": "Dcard 足球板轉貼", "url": "https://www.dcard.tw/f/soccer/p/262230436" }, { "id": "src-66", "published_at": "2025-07", "source_type": "Podcast 影音（利益揭露：本刊節目）", "title": "YouTube：只能喝酒的圖書館 EP112", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDuukdzemYc" }, { "id": "src-67", "published_at": "", "source_type": "專業團體網站列表", "title": "全聯會最新消息", "url": "https://www.tcpu.org.tw/news" }, { "id": "src-68", "published_at": "2026-04-09", "source_type": "立法院公報", "title": "立法院公報第 115 卷第 29 期", "url": "https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/PublicationOfficialGazettes/download/communique1/final/pdf/115/29/LCIDC01_1152902.pdf" }, { "id": "src-69", "published_at": "2026-08-25", "source_type": "行政院公報", "title": "行政院公報：運科補助作業要點修正", "url": "https://gazette.nat.gov.tw/egFront/eguploadpubWrapper?file=%2FEG_FileManager%2Feguploadpub%2Feg032157%2Fch05%2Ftype2%2Fgov89%2Fnum10%2FEg.htm&metaid=167863" }, { "id": "src-70", "published_at": "", "source_type": "機構文件", "title": "國家運動選手知情同意書", "url": "https://athlete-consent.tiss.org.tw/" }, { "id": "src-71", "published_at": "", "source_type": "國外機構", "title": "澳洲運動研究院倫理委員會", "url": "https://www.ausport.gov.au/ais/research-submissions/ec" }, { "id": "src-72", "published_at": "2025-02", "source_type": "國外專業守則", "title": "BASES 會員行為守則", "url": "https://www.bases.org.uk/imgs/code_of_conduct___february_2025458.pdf" }, { "id": "src-73", "published_at": "2026-09-30", "source_type": "民間團體新聞稿", "title": "人本新聞稿（公民行動影音紀錄資料庫）", "url": "https://www.civilmedia.tw/archives/141352" }, { "id": "src-74", "published_at": "2026-04-22", "source_type": "立法院議案", "title": "立委人體研究法修正草案", "url": "https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/download/agenda1/02/pdf/11/05/08/LCEWA01_110508_00051.pdf" }, { "id": "src-75", "published_at": "", "source_type": "立法院議案頁", "title": "立法院議案審議進度", "url": "https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/bills/202110208900000/details" }, { "id": "src-76", "published_at": "2026-04-10", "source_type": "法規", "title": "國科會專題研究計畫補助作業要點", "url": "https://law.nstc.gov.tw/LawContent.aspx?id=FL026713" }, { "id": "src-77", "published_at": "2026-02-06", "source_type": "法規", "title": "國科會學術倫理案件處理及審議要點", "url": "https://law.nstc.gov.tw/LawContent.aspx?id=FL044283" }, { "id": "src-78", "published_at": "2026-09-02", "source_type": "法規", "title": "教育部人體研究倫理審查會查核作業要點", "url": "https://edu.law.moe.gov.tw/LawContent.aspx?id=GL001049" }, { "id": "src-79", "published_at": "2025-06-18", "source_type": "法規沿革", "title": "教育部查核作業要點舊版", "url": "https://edu.law.moe.gov.tw/LawContentHistory.aspx?hid=205636&id=GL001049" }, { "id": "src-80", "published_at": "2026-08-17", "source_type": "法規", "title": "教育部不定期追蹤查核作業要點", "url": "https://edu.law.moe.gov.tw/LawContent.aspx?id=GL001495" }, { "id": "src-81", "published_at": "2026-09-15", "source_type": "政府政策說明", "title": "行政院：國民運動法草案", "url": "https://www.ey.gov.tw/Page/5A8A0CB5B41DA11E/2adffab9-d925-4c39-9fff-e09036337c2f" }, { "id": "src-63", "published_at": "2025-11-01", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社：撤銷博士學位", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/ahel/202511010218.aspx" } ], "unknowns": [ { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "北檢公開偵結新聞稿，或處分書、起訴書全文可在司法院或北檢網站查得。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-4", "e-src-64", "e-src-73" ], "id": "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-abba0e73780a", "question": "起訴書與不起訴處分書全文寫了什麼？檢方有沒有調閱國科會與教育部的研究倫理調查材料？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "國科會或教育部公開逐案調查報告，或監察院公布未省略的逐案表格。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-5", "e-src-14" ], "id": "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-454edb4fdf4c", "question": "國科會與教育部逐案調查中，每項研究抽了幾次、同意書何時簽、誰抽的血？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "教育部或衛福部公布 97 件查核結果與後續處分。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-33", "e-src-48" ], "id": "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-f3e90ac46f44", "question": "23 校 97 件含血液樣本研究的查核結果是什麼？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "法院判決對帳起訴書附表 2，或臺師大、監察院公開受試費對帳資料。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-3", "e-src-14", "e-src-15" ], "id": "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-bd18bf73c21c", "question": "138 萬、129.3 萬、122 萬三個受試費總額差在哪裡？學生有沒有拿回全部？", "status": "world_pending" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "全聯會、臺師大或教育部公布不涉個資的使用人數、延長公告與成效評估。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-30", "e-src-31", "e-src-67" ], "id": "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-a3f0cda5fca9", "question": "諮商專案與申訴窗口有多少人使用？2026 年 6 月底後有沒有延長？法律協助與復學說明幫了幾個人？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "運動部公開 2026-01-08 原函附件、補償標準，或申訴窗口受理統計。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-14", "e-src-26", "e-src-27" ], "id": "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-6e0cf8dd89f6", "question": "運動部有沒有退費以外的補償機制？申訴窗口受理了什麼、收過幾件？", "status": "holder_blocked" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "衛福部預告人體研究法修正草案，或公開對監察院的回覆函。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-12", "e-src-14", "e-src-74", "e-src-75" ], "id": "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-1559ee0e66c7", "question": "衛福部對人體研究法有沒有修法研議？它怎麼回覆監察院 2026 年 7 月的要求與北檢的函詢？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "立法院社福衛環委員會排審並有審查紀錄。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-74", "e-src-75" ], "id": "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-78016dd61dfc", "question": "立委人體研究法草案會不會排審？", "status": "world_pending" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "運動部或運科中心公開指引、保護委員會設置要點、逐案清查表或內部調查結論。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-14", "e-src-27", "e-src-68", "e-src-69" ], "id": "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-b21b929af394", "question": "運動部承諾的運科作業指引、參與者保護規範，以及運科中心保護委員會的設置規定與審查紀錄是什麼？289 件逐案清查表與女足案內部調查結論為何？", "status": "holder_blocked" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "教育部公告臺師大恢復收案、核定停聘，或公開查核評估意見。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-45", "e-src-47", "e-src-78" ], "id": "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-623f1068d85f", "question": "臺師大 IRB 是否已恢復收案？陳忠慶停聘是否已核定？教育部各校查核評估意見如何？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "臺北地方法院一審判決公開。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-3", "e-src-41" ], "id": "unknown-ntnu-womens-soccer-aftermath-48813eb1f49d", "question": "周台英的刑事案件，法院會怎麼判？", "status": "world_pending" } ] }