{ "claims": [ { "boundary": "五類只是總數，不能代表每棵樹的評估理由，也不能回答腐朽是否源於修剪。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-4" ], "id": "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-e6d957a707e2", "scope": { "geography": "台北市（公園處轄管行道樹）", "population": "公園處管理的行道樹", "time": "2025年（114年度）" }, "status": "supported", "text": "8月議會書面答復列明2025年公園處移除3,164株行道樹，分為自然死亡996、腐朽639、病蟲害522、其他原因534、天災473株。" }, { "boundary": "不能說哪個數字是捏造的，也不能說台北的樹確定淨減了多少；判斷取決於市府未公開的同口徑存量帳。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-4", "e-src-15", "e-src-28", "e-src-29" ], "id": "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7c49115358ac", "scope": { "geography": "台北市", "population": "公園處、大地處、都發局及工務局發布的樹木數字", "time": "2023–2026年9月" }, "status": "synthesis", "text": "市府拿一年的移除數（含天災）對照兩年、三個機關合計的13,225株種植；10/14又把未說明是否扣除移除與死亡的42,250株稱為「已增加」；同一個月帳面從20萬5千多株減到18萬603株，對議會卻寫「仍維持18萬餘株」。這些說法有誤導市民之虞。" }, { "boundary": "跨年審定總額不能當成單年實支，執行率也不證明錢用得恰當，或用在砍樹上。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-45", "e-src-46", "e-src-49", "e-src-53" ], "id": "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-e7cd191aff51", "scope": { "geography": "台北市", "population": "公園處樹木修剪工程科目", "time": "113–116年度" }, "status": "supported", "text": "「樹木修剪工程」跨兩年的審定總工程費，從113年度的1.07億元增至114年度的2.45億元；議會一元未刪，114年當年可支用經費執行約99.22%。" }, { "boundary": "只證明委員會公開審查時沒有人追問，不能排除議員在會後或其他場合要過資料。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-64" ], "id": "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7189d3bd0d59", "scope": { "geography": "台北市議會工務委員會", "population": "114年度公園處預算審查", "time": "2024-12-17" }, "status": "supported", "text": "翻倍那一年，議會工務委員會逐筆審到這一筆時，速記錄只有「沒意見，通過」。同一頁另兩筆預算，主席都問了「有增加嗎？」。" }, { "boundary": "評選分數與完整投標名冊尚未取得，不能判斷競爭是否充分。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-70", "e-src-71", "e-src-72" ], "id": "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7463aec792c7", "scope": { "geography": "台北市四區", "population": "行道樹修剪預約工程投標廠商", "time": "115年度" }, "status": "partially_supported", "text": "115年度修剪標的四個得標金額幾乎貼齊各區公開預算，四區合計只差2元；但這個差額不足以證明串通，競爭程度仍待核。" }, { "boundary": "撤回先前「由公園處打分」「評鑑結果該公開而沒公開」兩項說法；評鑑作業規定仍未取得。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-72" ], "id": "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-c1fe0f6cc5fd", "scope": { "geography": "台北市", "population": "115年度修剪標得標廠商", "time": "115–118年度續約期" }, "status": "corrected", "text": "投標須知規定，廠商通過服務品質評鑑才能續約；但它不能證明由誰評分，也不能證明評鑑已辦理或已有結果。" }, { "boundary": "不能說是2024年那次現勘增作剪壞的，也不能說6棵都已實際移除。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-6", "e-src-88" ], "id": "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-61bf9bf2d34f", "scope": { "geography": "台北市富民生態公園", "population": "公園處權管的一般樹木", "time": "2025年9月至2026年7月評估與會勘" }, "status": "supported", "text": "富民生態公園的官方評估表，把幾棵計畫移除的樹木缺陷寫成截頂、斷頭修剪或「修剪不當」留下的傷；最終計畫移除6棵，但沒有寫是誰、在哪一年剪的。" }, { "boundary": "2,989棵是列管應移除數，不代表已砍；改善進度的完成證明仍未取得。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-22", "e-src-23" ], "id": "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-a3dc5e3b8aed", "scope": { "geography": "台北市", "population": "公園處行道樹移除列管", "time": "2023–2024年列管，2025年7月報告" }, "status": "supported", "text": "審計部指出，公園處列管應移除的2,989棵樹「未訂定移除期限，亦未註記移除日期」，部分不移除的決策「查無決策資料可稽」。" }, { "boundary": "宣布處理不等於裁處已送達或求償已入帳；第一筆異常由誰、何時發現仍未查明。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-75", "e-src-76" ], "id": "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-4e597ffc7f81", "scope": { "geography": "台北市東門市場附近", "population": "單一移植工程個案", "time": "2026年5–9月" }, "status": "supported", "text": "東門茄苳原本不在移除之列，卻遭施工廠商砍掉。公園處宣布裁罰、求償32萬5,210元，並承認處理時間冗長；從廠商坦承到公開處理相隔四個多月。" } ], "evidence": [ { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-6b834ae743c8" ], "id": "e-src-1", "locator": "報導中的園區說明：感染褐根病、樹保委員會勘確認枯亡、為公共安全處理（報導未列樹號）", "source_id": "src-1", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-6b834ae743c8" ], "id": "e-src-2", "locator": "樹籍頁 #3917（雀榕）：樣本送林試所「確認感染褐根病」；7月24日會勘「同意解除列管」（9月25日以前讀取）", "source_id": "src-2", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-3", "locator": "報導段落：四區決標總額比預算少2元；議員質詢2023–2026年移除5,819棵、市長答兩年新種13,225棵", "source_id": "src-3", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-3708ce90f5ac", "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-848041cad1ec" ], "id": "e-src-4", "locator": "市府115年8月書面答復：第58頁（113年修剪5萬8,864株、114年8萬939株；114年度移除3,164棵）、第4頁（含天災473株）、第19頁（總量仍維持18萬餘株）", "source_id": "src-4", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7c49115358ac", "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-e6d957a707e2" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-5", "locator": "報導中樹醫說明：反覆強剪長期可能造成枝幹腐朽", "source_id": "src-5", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-e81e33d33cd3" ], "id": "e-src-6", "locator": "公園處富民生態公園計畫移除樹木評估表：「修剪不當」「曾斷頭修剪」記載", "source_id": "src-6", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-61bf9bf2d34f" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-6b834ae743c8" ], "id": "e-src-7", "locator": "小樹保衛站公開說明清單（2026年10月15日取得，65則，含松菸、天母及私人土地案件）", "source_id": "src-7", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-8", "locator": "手冊中褐根病「隱藏於地底，故不易察覺」、病徵出現時「通常根部已有80%以上」段落", "source_id": "src-8", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-9", "locator": "專欄作者稱文化局提供的診斷資料「沒有全株與樹冠的照片」", "source_id": "src-9", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-10", "locator": "報導：中山北路七段圓環老榕樹移除、網友質疑「看起來病得沒這麼嚴重啊？」", "source_id": "src-10", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-11", "locator": "公園處9月24日新聞稿轉載全文：2023/9/19倒樹、米格魯偵測、2023/10/2會勘確診、2024年藥劑灌注、6月18日移除", "source_id": "src-11", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-12", "locator": "報導中公園處說法：6月18日移除、2023年偵測、打藥治療、移除前公告", "source_id": "src-12", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-13", "locator": "115年1–8月行道樹移植資訊表第131列（大湖山莊街179號光蠟樹8月移至大湖山莊籃球場）；全表140列，月份4至8月", "source_id": "src-13", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-14", "locator": "標題「115年1–8月」專案申請行道樹移植資訊表；最早列月份為2月", "source_id": "src-14", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-3708ce90f5ac" ], "id": "e-src-15", "locator": "市府10月14日新聞稿：宣布「小樹保衛站」上線", "source_id": "src-15", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7c49115358ac" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-16", "locator": "報導中政治評論員稱網站「基本上是60則新聞稿」、去年移除3,164棵網站只寫約70棵；研考會主委「合理監督沒問題」", "source_id": "src-16", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-17", "locator": "報導轉述議員：2024年移除1,425株；2025年移除2,691株、天災減損473株", "source_id": "src-17", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-18", "locator": "市府112年11月答復：2024年起委外巡查20名、自有巡查12名，非破壞性儀器檢測「每年至少5,000株以上」", "source_id": "src-18", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-19", "locator": "市府112年12月答復：巡查人力與非破壞性儀器檢測每年至少5,000株", "source_id": "src-19", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-20", "locator": "工務局115年上半年施政報告中公園處樹木巡檢／檢測相關公布數據（頁碼未載）", "source_id": "src-20", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-21", "locator": "第24頁：2024年中山北路一段光達試辦摘要", "source_id": "src-21", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-22", "locator": "審計部113年度審核報告，工務局主管乙－70，第（六）項（公園處管理問題）", "source_id": "src-22", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-a3dc5e3b8aed" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-23", "locator": "審計部114年度審核報告：公園處逐棵移除列冊、作業流程修訂及流程電子化承諾（期限2026年6月底）", "source_id": "src-23", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-a3dc5e3b8aed" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-24", "locator": "報導轉述議員資料：2025年移除2,691與天災473相加為3,164", "source_id": "src-24", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-25", "locator": "文章轉述議員資料：2025年移除2,691與天災473相加為3,164", "source_id": "src-25", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-26", "locator": "報導轉述公園處說過去兩年「新增超過1.3萬棵」", "source_id": "src-26", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-27", "locator": "收錄之議員貼文（10月14日）：「台北已經種了42,250棵樹」", "source_id": "src-27", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-28", "locator": "報導中樹保團體引議員索資：公園處1,739棵、大地處4,842棵、建管處6,644棵（建照登載植栽）", "source_id": "src-28", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7c49115358ac" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-3708ce90f5ac" ], "id": "e-src-29", "locator": "議會工務委員會速記錄（8月17日）：議員依公園處附表質問112、113年20萬5千多株，期末18萬603株", "source_id": "src-29", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7c49115358ac" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-30", "locator": "專欄：「都市樹木真正珍貴的，不只是「株數」，而是它所形成的樹冠覆蓋率」", "source_id": "src-30", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-31", "locator": "網頁粗估：每棵樹冠16平方公尺×約10萬棵，樹冠占平地面積約1.3%（網頁未載估算年份）", "source_id": "src-31", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-32", "locator": "報導轉述沈聖峰Sentinel-2判讀：市街內部樹冠2024年628公頃降至2026年615公頃", "source_id": "src-32", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-33", "locator": "報導中市長「一定是依法來處置」；市議員「台北市政府居然要告市民！」", "source_id": "src-33", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-34", "locator": "報導：網紅公開傳票「第一次作為被告」；公園處「言論自由不能無限上綱」", "source_id": "src-34", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-35", "locator": "報導：四名轉發圖卡被告獲不起訴及轉述理由", "source_id": "src-35", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-36", "locator": "文化局9月29日新聞稿：受保護榕樹編號86，8月27日斷折、9月21日腐朽檢測", "source_id": "src-36", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-37", "locator": "報導：綠黨與護樹人士陳情（西園路二段226號、牯嶺街、立法院旁案例）", "source_id": "src-37", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-38", "locator": "綠黨9月23日新聞稿：陳情案例與1999「罐頭公文」回覆", "source_id": "src-38", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-39", "locator": "公園處114年2月處務會議紀錄：處長裁示「遣詞用字及回答技巧應再多加注意」", "source_id": "src-39", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-40", "locator": "公園處114年3月處務會議紀錄：「一定應第一時間打電話詢問」裁示", "source_id": "src-40", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-41", "locator": "報導：富民生態公園整建計畫移除11棵、移植6棵；台灣樹人會與里長說法", "source_id": "src-41", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-42", "locator": "113年度招標公告：「擴充金額均為7,300萬元，預估期間均為1年3個月」；每區預算約2,474萬元", "source_id": "src-42", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-43", "locator": "111年度標案：「預估後續擴充之金額總計新臺幣1億6,000萬元整」", "source_id": "src-43", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-44", "locator": "北區續約附加說明：「原招標文件已有載明後續擴充以原契約條件及價金續約核算付款，以換文方式辦理」；限制性招標、決標5,300萬元", "source_id": "src-44", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-45", "locator": "「樹木修剪工程」科目：112年度1億137萬元、113年度1億700萬元", "source_id": "src-45", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-e7cd191aff51" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-46", "locator": "第88–89頁「樹木修剪工程」科目：總經費2億4,530萬8,000元", "source_id": "src-46", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-e7cd191aff51" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-47", "locator": "「樹木修剪工程」科目：總經費2億4,530萬8,000元、施工費2億4,174萬594元", "source_id": "src-47", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-48", "locator": "114年度總預算案送議會日期（2024年8月27日）", "source_id": "src-48", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-49", "locator": "第88頁「總工程費擬編列245,308,000元」；第15頁綠化工程12項較上年度增加202,870,000元", "source_id": "src-49", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-e7cd191aff51" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-50", "locator": "公園處114年度第一次追加預算：路燈電價調漲", "source_id": "src-50", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-51", "locator": "公園處114年度第二次追加預算：中央補助兒童遊戲場改善", "source_id": "src-51", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-848041cad1ec" ], "id": "e-src-52", "locator": "樹木修剪工程科目頁：需求來源「市民反映」、計畫內容五項（全市委外巡檢四區每區每日8人）", "source_id": "src-52", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-848041cad1ec" ], "id": "e-src-53", "locator": "第148–149頁重大計畫執行表：可用2億2,165萬元、執行2億1,991萬元、執行率99.22%", "source_id": "src-53", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-e7cd191aff51" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-54", "locator": "重大計畫執行表：可用9,600萬元、執行9,433萬元、執行率98.26%", "source_id": "src-54", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-55", "locator": "第123頁：可用9,702萬元，全數執行", "source_id": "src-55", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-56", "locator": "第19頁：114年1至8月「修剪行道樹5萬3,450株」", "source_id": "src-56", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-57", "locator": "公園處114年1月處務會議紀錄：「提報本處行道樹修剪棵數」", "source_id": "src-57", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-58", "locator": "公園處114年4月處務會議紀錄：「提報本處行道樹修剪棵數」", "source_id": "src-58", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-59", "locator": "地方制度法第40條：議會「不得為增加支出之提議」", "source_id": "src-59", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-60", "locator": "2023年8月30日報導全文（引文段落截斷，未載具體段落）", "source_id": "src-60", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-61", "locator": "報導中公園處說明：金額「係依招標文件所定服務內容、工作項目及數量編列」、巡查後確認才開單", "source_id": "src-61", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-62", "locator": "報導中市長「這是最有利標，一切合法合規」", "source_id": "src-62", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-63", "locator": "報導中參選人稱市府「問A答B」", "source_id": "src-63", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-64", "locator": "113/12/17工務分組審查速記錄：樹木修剪工程「好，這有沒有意見？沒意見，通過。」", "source_id": "src-64", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7189d3bd0d59" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-65", "locator": "112/12/14審查速記錄：113年度樹木修剪工程審查段落", "source_id": "src-65", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-66", "locator": "114/12/19速記錄：籠統項目暫擱、連續工程編列追問、工務局長答應檢討", "source_id": "src-66", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-67", "locator": "第87頁：116年度樹木修剪工程2億4,530萬8,000元、施工費2億2,103萬7,745元、116-117年度連續工程", "source_id": "src-67", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-ce389b8694b7" ], "id": "e-src-68", "locator": "10月6日第二輪審查：樹木工程5筆暫擱移第三輪", "source_id": "src-68", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-ce389b8694b7" ], "id": "e-src-69", "locator": "工務委員會正式會議紀錄：公園處綠化工程暫擱／通過項目", "source_id": "src-69", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-70", "locator": "招標公告：四區預算（北52,445,152、南52,445,004、西52,445,151、東52,445,144元）；後續擴充四區各1億4,600萬元", "source_id": "src-70", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7463aec792c7" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-71", "locator": "決標頁：四家得標標價；10月14日取得之加值決標頁未得標列52,435,152元", "source_id": "src-71", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7463aec792c7" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-948df6d91d9d" ], "id": "e-src-72", "locator": "投標須知：後續擴充拆分；「評鑑合格得以原契約單價、條件辦理續約」條款", "source_id": "src-72", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7463aec792c7", "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-c1fe0f6cc5fd" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-73", "locator": "報導轉述規範書：基本工作點數、不足每點罰500元及各項點數", "source_id": "src-73", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-74", "locator": "報導：東門市場茄苳遭委外廠商整棵砍除；議員「每一道程序分開看都有規定…」", "source_id": "src-74", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-75", "locator": "公園處9月22日新聞稿：廠商「已於5月5日坦承疏失」、求償32萬5,210元、終止契約、政風調查", "source_id": "src-75", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-4e597ffc7f81" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-76", "locator": "報導：東門茄苳案公園處裁罰、求償與懲處說明", "source_id": "src-76", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-4e597ffc7f81" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-77", "locator": "捷運局9月16日新聞稿：建國中學外樹穴清除6棵、回填沃土", "source_id": "src-77", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-78", "locator": "2022年移植規範第5.1點（重要施工階段會同查驗）、第3點（施工前核對樹種、規格、數量及編號）", "source_id": "src-78", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-79", "locator": "公園處9月21日新聞稿現存版本（頁面標9月29日更新）：監造人員現場確認工法", "source_id": "src-79", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-80", "locator": "2025年3月民權東路遊覽車撞行道樹事故調查報告：修剪廠商事故前已通報樹幹傾斜並綁警示帶", "source_id": "src-80", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-81", "locator": "運安會改善建議頁：檢查淨高、調整車道兩項建議", "source_id": "src-81", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-82", "locator": "改善建議第一項：狀態「等候回覆或處理中」，最後異動2026年5月14日", "source_id": "src-82", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-83", "locator": "改善建議第二項：狀態「等候回覆或處理中」，最後異動2026年5月14日", "source_id": "src-83", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-84", "locator": "首頁標2022年5月16日修正生效；截頂條件、截幹／斷頭禁令、第7.2點施工前通知", "source_id": "src-84", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-85", "locator": "113年度審核報告工務局主管：2022年至2024年10月底倒塌590件、颱風342件、內部或基部腐朽87件、豪大雨68件", "source_id": "src-85", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-86", "locator": "報導中林試所副所長：關鍵在「實際施作人員有沒有依照這些規範」", "source_id": "src-86", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-e81e33d33cd3" ], "id": "e-src-87", "locator": "第48頁：圓山公園管理所加班報表「富民生態公園樹木修剪現勘案增作事宜」", "source_id": "src-87", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-88", "locator": "第3頁：富民工區181棵一般樹木「移除11株、移植6株」、164棵原地保留", "source_id": "src-88", "supports": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-61bf9bf2d34f" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-89", "locator": "第20頁（受保護榕樹「確認現場已無樹木」）、第23頁（解除列管名單）", "source_id": "src-89", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-90", "locator": "第42–46頁解除列管名單；第44頁北投褐根病榕樹（2023年6月9日現勘）", "source_id": "src-90", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-91", "locator": "第24–25頁：風險四級、重大危害即時簽報移除、高風險須2位專家會勘", "source_id": "src-91", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-92", "locator": "第八點：逐株評估、說明會、審查、核准計畫公告於官網", "source_id": "src-92", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-93", "locator": "新聞稿：公園處管理約9萬棵行道樹（2017年數字）", "source_id": "src-93", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-94", "locator": "報導：高雄兩百年感染褐根病榕樹，廟方選擇保留", "source_id": "src-94", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-95", "locator": "第3–7段：都市道路街樹砍伐前諮詢公眾義務及適用範圍", "source_id": "src-95", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-96", "locator": "樹木工程計畫表（2025年3月21日更新版）：砍伐、修剪、種植計畫", "source_id": "src-96", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-97", "locator": "Forestry Work Orders 資料集", "source_id": "src-97", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-98", "locator": "Forestry Risk Assessments 資料集", "source_id": "src-98", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-99", "locator": "第7頁：樹冠覆蓋率以22%為起點，目標2040年達40%", "source_id": "src-99", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-100", "locator": "市政法典第813章：私有地健康大樹原則上不准砍", "source_id": "src-100", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-101", "locator": "新聞公報：古樹名木因褐根病移除前諮詢專家與區議會", "source_id": "src-101", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-102", "locator": "調查結論：契約寫入替換17,500棵；數千棵健康樹被砍屬嚴重策略領導失敗", "source_id": "src-102", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-103", "locator": "報導：撫遠公園77棵榕樹列移除，4位專家重勘後移除56棵、保留21棵；第二意見制度主張", "source_id": "src-103", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-104", "locator": "File No. 251211 案件頁及所附通過版條文（30天通知、聽證、上訴；第8節生效規定）", "source_id": "src-104", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-105", "locator": "市府7月8日新聞稿：預定修剪資訊「皆定期公告於公園處官網」", "source_id": "src-105", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-106", "locator": "報導：公園處「預計年底前」完成移除、修剪等流程電子化", "source_id": "src-106", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-107", "locator": "報導：公園處對媒體承諾年底前優化資訊網", "source_id": "src-107", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-108", "locator": "報導：各案轉交權責機關「於6至30天內提出正式書面回覆」", "source_id": "src-108", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-109", "locator": "報導：五年「修剪」8萬棵", "source_id": "src-109", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-110", "locator": "解除列管流程圖文字與註2（索引標示2021年異動）", "source_id": "src-110", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-111", "locator": "第3頁：「本次解除受保護樹木計28株，准予備查」", "source_id": "src-111", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-112", "locator": "2011年版第4條：明列迅速搶修、補植", "source_id": "src-112", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-113", "locator": "2024年版第4條：改為適當處理", "source_id": "src-113", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-114", "locator": "第6點：特定移植之保活及復植要求", "source_id": "src-114", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-115", "locator": "9月16日幹事會紀錄全文11頁（未見#2250或東和公園事項）", "source_id": "src-115", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-116", "locator": "標示113.04.09修訂之評估表彙編（引用評估流程名稱）", "source_id": "src-116", "supports": [] } ], "inquiry": { "id": "pursuit_ed805d6a0f1115b9e421", "reader_promise": "市府已有總數、集中說明網站與部分個案說明，但移除與種植數字口徑不一，修剪經費翻倍後只公開全市總帳。修剪傷害造成的「腐朽」，也還沒有接回當年是誰剪的。", "root_question": "台北砍樹爭議：市府的樹木數字前後對不上，逐樹依據與責任仍接不起來", "updated_at": "2026-10-19T06:21:20+00:00" }, "queries": [ { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-e6d957a707e2", "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7c49115358ac", "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-e7cd191aff51", "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7189d3bd0d59", "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7463aec792c7", "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-c1fe0f6cc5fd", "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-61bf9bf2d34f", "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-a3dc5e3b8aed", "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-4e597ffc7f81" ], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-3708ce90f5ac", "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-948df6d91d9d", "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-848041cad1ec", "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-e81e33d33cd3", "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-6b834ae743c8", "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-ce389b8694b7" ] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-2e3b79e7dbcf", "text": "台北砍樹爭議：市府的樹木數字前後對不上，逐樹依據與責任仍接不起來" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-e6d957a707e2" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-e6d957a707e2", "text": "8月議會書面答復列明2025年公園處移除3,164株行道樹，分為自然死亡996、腐朽639、病蟲害522、其他原因534、天災473株。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7c49115358ac" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-7c49115358ac", "text": "市府拿一年的移除數（含天災）對照兩年、三個機關合計的13,225株種植；10/14又把未說明是否扣除移除與死亡的42,250株稱為「已增加」；同一個月帳面從20萬5千多株減到18萬603株，對議會卻寫「仍維持18萬餘株」。這些說法有誤導市民之虞。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-e7cd191aff51" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-e7cd191aff51", "text": "「樹木修剪工程」跨兩年的審定總工程費，從113年度的1.07億元增至114年度的2.45億元；議會一元未刪，114年當年可支用經費執行約99.22%。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7189d3bd0d59" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-7189d3bd0d59", "text": "翻倍那一年，議會工務委員會逐筆審到這一筆時，速記錄只有「沒意見，通過」。同一頁另兩筆預算，主席都問了「有增加嗎？」。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-7463aec792c7" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-7463aec792c7", "text": "115年度修剪標的四個得標金額幾乎貼齊各區公開預算，四區合計只差2元；但這個差額不足以證明串通，競爭程度仍待核。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-c1fe0f6cc5fd" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-c1fe0f6cc5fd", "text": "投標須知規定，廠商通過服務品質評鑑才能續約；但它不能證明由誰評分，也不能證明評鑑已辦理或已有結果。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-61bf9bf2d34f" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-61bf9bf2d34f", "text": "富民生態公園的官方評估表，把幾棵計畫移除的樹木缺陷寫成截頂、斷頭修剪或「修剪不當」留下的傷；最終計畫移除6棵，但沒有寫是誰、在哪一年剪的。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-a3dc5e3b8aed" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-a3dc5e3b8aed", "text": "審計部指出，公園處列管應移除的2,989棵樹「未訂定移除期限，亦未註記移除日期」，部分不移除的決策「查無決策資料可稽」。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-taipei-street-tree-removal-4e597ffc7f81" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-4e597ffc7f81", "text": "東門茄苳原本不在移除之列，卻遭施工廠商砍掉。公園處宣布裁罰、求償32萬5,210元，並承認處理時間冗長；從廠商坦承到公開處理相隔四個多月。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-3708ce90f5ac" ] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-3708ce90f5ac", "text": "台北市樹木的同口徑存量帳：期初存量、種植、移除、天災、移撥與期末存量。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-948df6d91d9d" ] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-948df6d91d9d", "text": "服務品質評鑑作業規定：由誰評分、評哪些項目、門檻多少、是否已辦理。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-848041cad1ec" ] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-848041cad1ec", "text": "多出的一億多元修剪經費，巡檢、維護型修剪與全樹型修剪各占多少，剪了哪些路段、哪些樹？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-e81e33d33cd3" ] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-e81e33d33cd3", "text": "富民評估表所寫的截頂與斷頭修剪，是哪一年、由誰施作？有沒有追責？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-6b834ae743c8" ] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-6b834ae743c8", "text": "#3917的林試所檢驗報告、7/24會勘紀錄與移除核准文件。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-ce389b8694b7" ] }, "id": "query-taipei-street-tree-removal-ce389b8694b7", "text": "116年度修剪預算在議會第三輪審查的個別結果與速記錄。" } ], "schema": "walkingbook-public-knowledge-v0", "source": { "path": "docs/product/evidence/walkingbook-question-0921fb684cd18b8c-editorial-review.md", "sha256": "986bd85eb1c7321e00674788576bbe4b31c31ac43c7b62322f089c8883493570" }, "sources": [ { "id": "src-1", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "園區說明報導", "url": "https://www.setn.com/news/1907788" }, { "id": "src-2", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府樹籍資料頁", "title": "文化局樹籍", "url": "https://eculture.gov.taipei/trees/zh-tw/tree/3917" }, { "id": "src-3", "published_at": "2026-09-16", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "三立新聞網 9/16", "url": "https://www.setn.com/news/1908130" }, { "id": "src-4", "published_at": "2026-08", "source_type": "議會書面答復（PDF）", "title": "議會書面答復", "url": "https://obasfront.tcc.gov.tw/Agenda/DownloadFile.aspx?FileName=202600004915.pdf&FilePath=202608&FileGrpKind=1" }, { "id": "src-5", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "樹醫說明", "url": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/life/breakingnews/5504663" }, { "id": "src-6", "published_at": "", "source_type": "官方評估表（PDF）", "title": "富民評估", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/001/Upload/348/relfile/68517/9712005/6b6674ce-29ed-4566-9850-b907003ee39c.pdf" }, { "id": "src-7", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府網站", "title": "小樹保衛站", "url": "https://treesmatch.gov.taipei/pkl/public/tree-map" }, { "id": "src-8", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府作業手冊（PDF）", "title": "褐根病防治作業手冊", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/001/Upload/356/relfile/16485/5142/853e986c-73c1-4bce-a068-7096c7d17b6b.pdf" }, { "id": "src-9", "published_at": "", "source_type": "評論專欄", "title": "自由評論網", "url": "https://talk.ltn.com.tw/article/breakingnews/5582028" }, { "id": "src-10", "published_at": "2026-09-26", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "太報 9/26", "url": "https://www.taisounds.com/news/content/93/290683" }, { "id": "src-11", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞稿轉載", "title": "公園處9/24說明的同稿轉載", "url": "https://newsday.tw/news/578563" }, { "id": "src-12", "published_at": "2026-09-24", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "鏡新聞 9/24", "url": "https://www.mnews.tw/story/amp/20260924nm015" }, { "id": "src-13", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府資料表（PDF）", "title": "行道樹移植資訊", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=..pdf&n=MTE15bm0MS045pyI6KGM6YGT5qi556e75qSN6LOH6KiKLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvNjg1NDMvOTcxNDE0OC9jMGJkNDNhMC04OTg5LTQyMjgtOTYxMC02ZjJiMmEwYTAyY2QucGRm" }, { "id": "src-14", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府資料表（PDF）", "title": "專案申請表", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=..pdf&n=MTE15bm0MS045pyI5bCI5qGI55Sz6KuL6KGM6YGT5qi556e75qSN6LOH6KiKLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvNjg1NDMvOTcxNDE0OC9kYjFjNzFkZC0zMGQ3LTQ4ZDAtYmFmZC1lNTQxYTg3MjhiYzMucGRm" }, { "id": "src-15", "published_at": "2026-10-14", "source_type": "市府新聞稿", "title": "「小樹保衛站」上線", "url": "https://www.gov.taipei/News_Content.aspx?n=F0DDAF49B89E9413&s=D4BC8C2761376398&sms=72544237BBE4C5F6" }, { "id": "src-16", "published_at": "2026-10-14", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "Newtalk 報導", "url": "https://newtalk.tw/news/view/2026-10-14/1065522" }, { "id": "src-17", "published_at": "2026-07-09", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "媒體轉述議員", "url": "https://news.pchome.com.tw/society/tcpttw/20260709/index-78360572680103334002.html" }, { "id": "src-18", "published_at": "2023-11", "source_type": "議會答復（報導者觀測站轉載）", "title": "市府 112 年 11 月答復", "url": "https://lawmaker.twreporter.org/council/bill/taipei-34141" }, { "id": "src-19", "published_at": "2023-12", "source_type": "議會答復（報導者觀測站轉載）", "title": "112 年 12 月答復", "url": "https://lawmaker.twreporter.org/council/bill/taipei-34195" }, { "id": "src-20", "published_at": "", "source_type": "施政報告（PDF）", "title": "工務局 115 年上半年施政報告", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=.pdf&n=5bel5YuZ5bGAMTQtN%2BW3peS9nOWgseWRiijlrprnqL%2FniYgpLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ0L3JlbGZpbGUvMTcwOTAvOTU3OTkyNS9lMTZhMmRjNi1jMmUzLTQzMGUtYjY4MS02YTNhYTlhZDM5MDcucGRm" }, { "id": "src-21", "published_at": "2025-04", "source_type": "議會工作報告（PDF）", "title": "工務局2025年4月工作報告", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?n=5bel5YuZ5bGAMTQtNeitsOacg%2BW3peS9nOWgseWRilY1KDAzMjXljbDliLfniYgpLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ0L3JlbGZpbGUvMTcwOTAvOTM5ODE4Mi85YzA5ZDYyOC03OTYxLTRjYmItODNhZi0zZmE1ZGY2ZDg2Y2QucGRm" }, { "id": "src-22", "published_at": "", "source_type": "審計報告", "title": "審核報告", "url": "https://auditreport.audit.gov.tw/ServerFile/Get/638892895958471868507c8410ecfb40ad981878324cbc5200" }, { "id": "src-23", "published_at": "", "source_type": "審計報告", "title": "114年度報告", "url": "https://auditreport.audit.gov.tw/ServerFile/Get/63921016727310813905508cdae4bd4d62891d1493e6be631f" }, { "id": "src-24", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "太報", "url": "https://dev.taisounds.news/news/content/93/292492" }, { "id": "src-25", "published_at": "", "source_type": "電子報文章", "title": "Entropy Clinic", "url": "https://entropyclinic.substack.com/p/872" }, { "id": "src-26", "published_at": "2026-09-26", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "太報9/26", "url": "https://www.taisounds.com/news/content/89/290816" }, { "id": "src-27", "published_at": "", "source_type": "社群貼文收錄", "title": "貼文收錄", "url": "https://knowledge.kmt.org.tw/articles/289952fd-33d2-4e42-9baa-83c26b4ce9bc/" }, { "id": "src-28", "published_at": "2026-09-30", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aloc/202609300337.aspx" }, { "id": "src-29", "published_at": "2026-08-17", "source_type": "議會速記錄", "title": "速記錄", "url": "https://obasfront.tcc.gov.tw/Agenda/DownloadFile.aspx?FileName=14108%E5%B7%A5%E9%83%A8%E9%96%8002-1.doc&FilePath=&FileGrpKind=3" }, { "id": "src-30", "published_at": "", "source_type": "評論專欄", "title": "鏡週刊專欄", "url": "https://www.mirrormedia.mg/external/dailycolumn_87254" }, { "id": "src-31", "published_at": "", "source_type": "基金會網頁", "title": "台北樹都", "url": "https://www.eqpf.org/treecapital/school.html" }, { "id": "src-32", "published_at": "2026-09-26", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "太報 9/26", "url": "https://www.taisounds.com/news/content/91/290808" }, { "id": "src-33", "published_at": "2026-07-13", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "ETtoday", "url": "https://www.ettoday.net/news/20260713/3200100.htm" }, { "id": "src-34", "published_at": "2026-09-24", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "四季線上", "url": "https://www.4gtv.tv/article/2026092409000025" }, { "id": "src-35", "published_at": "2026-10-13", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "太報 10/13 報導", "url": "https://www.taisounds.com/news/content/95/293783" }, { "id": "src-36", "published_at": "2026-09-29", "source_type": "政府新聞稿", "title": "文化局 9/29 新聞稿", "url": "https://www.gov.taipei/News_Content.aspx?n=F0DDAF49B89E9413&s=D09F1BF456D201A8&sms=72544237BBE4C5F6" }, { "id": "src-37", "published_at": "2026-09-23", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "自由時報 9/23", "url": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/Taipei/breakingnews/5583444" }, { "id": "src-38", "published_at": "2026-09-23", "source_type": "政黨新聞稿", "title": "綠黨 9/23 新聞稿", "url": "https://www.greenparty.org.tw/posts/news/news-0923-taipei-tree/" }, { "id": "src-39", "published_at": "2025-02", "source_type": "機關會議紀錄（PDF）", "title": "2月會議原件", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=..pdf&n=MTE05bm0MuaciOS7veiZleWLmeacg%2BitsOe0gOmMhC5wZGY%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMzE2OTAvOTM2Njk3Ny83MDVhNmIxOC1iYTBhLTRhNzktYWU5NS00MzliM2EyNzMyNTkucGRm" }, { "id": "src-40", "published_at": "2025-03", "source_type": "機關會議紀錄（PDF）", "title": "3月會議原件", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=..pdf&n=MTE05bm0M%2BaciOS7veiZleWLmeacg%2BitsOe0gOmMhC5wZGY%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMzE2OTAvOTM4MjY5My9jNDhjOThhOC0zYzY2LTRmNGUtYjNlNS1jOTcxZDgwYTIyNmEucGRm" }, { "id": "src-41", "published_at": "2026-07", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "公視我們的島", "url": "https://ourisland.pts.org.tw/content/12025" }, { "id": "src-42", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府採購公告", "title": "113 年度招標公告", "url": "https://web.pcc.gov.tw/prkms/urlSelector/common/tpam?pk=NzA0ODk5ODk=" }, { "id": "src-43", "published_at": "", "source_type": "採購資料彙整網頁", "title": "111 年度標案", "url": "https://ezbid.tw/detail/3.79.11.3/111A046" }, { "id": "src-44", "published_at": "", "source_type": "採購資料彙整網頁", "title": "北區續約", "url": "https://ezbid.tw/detail/3.79.11.3/1121218C0134-A-Y01" }, { "id": "src-45", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法定預算書（PDF）", "title": "113 年度預算書", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMTAxMjMvOTEzMjcwNi8yMGEyZjBiYS0xZGMyLTQzNTQtYTdjZC1jN2E5MTM4NWMwYmQucGRm&n=5YWs5ZyS6JmVMTEz5bm05bqm5rOV5a6a6aCQ566X5pu4KFBERikucGRm&icon=.pdf" }, { "id": "src-46", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法定預算書（PDF）", "title": "114 年度預算書", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMTAxMjMvOTM1NzgzMS85YTU2NWNlNS01YWUyLTQzMzYtODNjNS0zYmE2NjJiMGI2ZjMucGRm&n=5YWs5ZyS6JmVMTE05bm05bqm5rOV5a6a6aCQ566X5pu4KFBERikucGRm&icon=.pdf" }, { "id": "src-47", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法定預算書（PDF）", "title": "115 年度預算書", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMTAxMjMvOTU0MjgyNi80YmRiNDQzOC00NTJlLTRmMjgtYjFhMy0wYWJkYzg5OGZjODcucGRm&n=5YWs5ZyS6JmVMTE15bm05bqm5rOV5a6a6aCQ566X5pu4KFBERikucGRm&icon=.pdf" }, { "id": "src-48", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府預算網頁", "title": "主計處 114 年度法定預算", "url": "https://w2.dbas.gov.taipei/budget/ofbudget/114budget/BUDGET/afbud/index.htm" }, { "id": "src-49", "published_at": "", "source_type": "預算案（PDF）", "title": "114 年度預算案", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/001/Upload/348/relfile/10123/9265489/0b83ac06-789c-42fd-8bb2-d1889cb3b9f5.pdf" }, { "id": "src-50", "published_at": "", "source_type": "追加預算書（PDF）", "title": "第一次追加", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMTAxMjMvOTQ0MjIwMi81YzdhM2Q3YS1iNjJiLTQyNDctYmNkNS1mZjBlMTA0MWZlYWEucGRm&n=5YWs5ZyS6JmVMTE05bm05bqm56ys5LiA5qyh6L%2b95YqgKOa4mynms5XlrprpoJDnrpfmm7goUERGKS5wZGY%3d&icon=.pdf" }, { "id": "src-51", "published_at": "", "source_type": "追加預算書（PDF）", "title": "第二次追加", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMTAxMjMvOTUzNjg1NC9hOWRiZjFlNi02NzQ5LTRlYzEtODE4Yy04ZDdlOGMxNTcxNDYucGRm&n=5YWs5ZyS6JmVMTE05bm05bqm56ys5LqM5qyh6L%2b95YqgKOa4mynms5XlrprpoJDnrpfmm7goUERGKS5wZGY%3d&icon=.pdf" }, { "id": "src-52", "published_at": "", "source_type": "計畫說明書（PDF）", "title": "114 年度新興繼續性計畫說明書", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=.pdf&n=MTE05bm05bqm5q2y5Ye66aCQ566X5qGI5paw6IiI57m857qM5oCn6KiI55Wr6Kqq5piO5pu4KOe4vee2k%2BiyuzUsMDAw6JCs5YWDKOWQqynku6XkuIopLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ0L3JlbGZpbGUvNTEzMjUvOTI5MjY0OS9kOTUwODU2Yi01ZGMwLTRkMmUtODVmNC03Y2FjYTE2MjkzMWMucGRm" }, { "id": "src-53", "published_at": "", "source_type": "決算書（PDF）", "title": "114 年度決算書", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMzExMTQvOTU3MDMzNi85ZmI5MjYxZi03NmZiLTQwNzktODEwMy1kODVhMTE5NDQ0OWYucGRm&n=5YWs5ZyS6JmVMTE05bm05bqm5Zau5L2N5rG6566X5pu4LnBkZg%3d%3d&icon=.pdf" }, { "id": "src-54", "published_at": "", "source_type": "決算書（PDF）", "title": "113 年度決算書", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMzExMTQvOTM5OTI0MC9mYzM5NTQ2My0wOGU1LTQyNmEtOTMyYy02N2VkNDc3MzRkZjUucGRm&n=KOabtOaWsCnlhazlnJLomZUxMTPlubTluqbllq7kvY3msbrnrpfmm7goUERGKS5wZGY%3d&icon=.pdf" }, { "id": "src-55", "published_at": "", "source_type": "決算書（PDF）", "title": "112 年度決算書", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=.pdf&n=KOWFrOWRiueUqCkxMTMwMi0wNzE1M%2BWFrOWckuiZlS0wMy0wMTAt5rG6566X5pu4LnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMzExMTQvOTE2MzY5OC9lNDMwMDU0YS04MjQxLTRlOTAtYTgxYi04ZmFjNGQ4Njk2ZGUucGRm" }, { "id": "src-56", "published_at": "2025-10", "source_type": "議會工作報告（PDF）", "title": "工務局 114 年 10 月工作報告", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=.pdf&n=MTE05bm05LiL5Y2K5bm05pa95pS%2F5aCx5ZGKLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ0L3JlbGZpbGUvMTcwOTAvOTQ4MjA5OC8yYWJkNmVjZi05MWMzLTRjYWMtODc3Zi1lY2IxMjNhMzdiNWMucGRm" }, { "id": "src-57", "published_at": "2025-01", "source_type": "機關會議紀錄（PDF）", "title": "1月原件", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=..pdf&n=MTE05bm0MeaciOS7veiZleWLmeacg%2BitsOe0gOmMhC5wZGY%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMzE2OTAvOTM0NTE0OC9kMmRkZGNlYy1kNjk1LTQ4NmQtOGMwYS01MjcxNGRiYjE1ZjcucGRm" }, { "id": "src-58", "published_at": "2025-04", "source_type": "機關會議紀錄（PDF）", "title": "4月原件", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=..pdf&n=MTE05bm0NOaciOS7veiZleWLmeacg%2BitsOe0gOmMhCjmoLjlrpopLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMzE2OTAvOTM5NjY1OS9jN2I4MWJhMS0xOWIzLTQ3NjItOWExNC1kNGNhNmU0ZDBiM2UucGRm" }, { "id": "src-59", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規條文", "title": "地方制度法第 40 條", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawSingle.aspx?pcode=A0040003&flno=40" }, { "id": "src-60", "published_at": "2023-08-30", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社 2023/8/30", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/asoc/202308300214.aspx" }, { "id": "src-61", "published_at": "2026-09-16", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "自由時報 9/16", "url": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/politics/breakingnews/5576403" }, { "id": "src-62", "published_at": "2026-09-21", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社 9/21", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aloc/202609210158.aspx" }, { "id": "src-63", "published_at": "2026-09-17", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "三立新聞網 9/17", "url": "https://www.setn.com/news/1908539" }, { "id": "src-64", "published_at": "2024-12-17", "source_type": "議會速記錄", "title": "議會工務分組審查速記錄 113/12/17", "url": "https://gaz.tcc.gov.tw/topic-list/h-rr/7F4CBF012F35EC42D0CA634C9260FD86/info.html" }, { "id": "src-65", "published_at": "2023-12-14", "source_type": "議會速記錄", "title": "速記錄 112/12/14", "url": "https://gaz.tcc.gov.tw/topic-list/h-rr/45C1544C80F2344629497C7FF39D7366/info.html" }, { "id": "src-66", "published_at": "2025-12-19", "source_type": "議會速記錄", "title": "速記錄 114/12/19", "url": "https://gaz.tcc.gov.tw/topic-list/h-rr/21AF0DDDC72F48810FA56FB975FA0671/info.html" }, { "id": "src-67", "published_at": "", "source_type": "預算案（PDF）", "title": "公園處 116 年度預算案", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=.pdf&n=5YWs5ZyS6JmVMTE25bm06aCQ566X5qGI5pu4LnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzQ4L3JlbGZpbGUvMTAxMjMvOTY3OTk2OC8wNDk4ZmNmOC04ODEyLTQyM2QtYjA5Yi0yZGI4NTQ2ZGU1NTQucGRm" }, { "id": "src-68", "published_at": "2026-10-06", "source_type": "議會會議紀錄", "title": "工務委員會 10/6 會議紀錄", "url": "https://gaz.tcc.gov.tw/topic-list/h-mt/BA90B841263BD1AF2C350C0527C61F09/info.html" }, { "id": "src-69", "published_at": "", "source_type": "議會會議紀錄", "title": "正式會議紀錄", "url": "https://gaz.tcc.gov.tw/topic-list/h-mt/994858ABBB6174345A8D9D99582C393B/info.html" }, { "id": "src-70", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府採購公告", "title": "採購網招標公告", "url": "https://web.pcc.gov.tw/prkms/urlSelector/common/tpam?pk=NzExMjM2Mjk=" }, { "id": "src-71", "published_at": "", "source_type": "採購資料彙整網頁", "title": "115 年度決標", "url": "https://ezbid.tw/detail/3.79.11/1150108C0006" }, { "id": "src-72", "published_at": "", "source_type": "招標文件（PDF）", "title": "115 年度投標須知", "url": "https://web.pcc.gov.tw/tps/QueryTender/query/downloadNoticeDocument?docType=1&pdt=2025-12-26&orgId=3.79.11&cno=1150108C0006&seq=01&UpdSq=01&pkPmsMain=NzExMjM2Mjk=" }, { "id": "src-73", "published_at": "2026-10-09", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "太報 10 月 9 日報導", "url": "https://dev.taisounds.news/news/content/93/292324" }, { "id": "src-74", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "自由時報", "url": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/amp/news/politics/breakingnews/5580553" }, { "id": "src-75", "published_at": "2026-09-22", "source_type": "政府新聞稿", "title": "公園處 9/22 新聞稿", "url": "https://www.gov.taipei/News_Content.aspx?n=74806083EBDF5A03&s=CB71C5F458062BF7&sms=72544237BBE4C5F6" }, { "id": "src-76", "published_at": "2026-09-22", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "知新聞 9/22", "url": "https://www.knews.com.tw/news/E4B7647439E28432C8B6CC4B126E6AB7" }, { "id": "src-77", "published_at": "2026-09-16", "source_type": "政府新聞稿", "title": "捷運局 9/16 新聞稿", "url": "https://www.dorts.gov.taipei/News_Content_table.aspx?n=41977EB83537C82B&s=BC73ED50679D720A&sms=72544237BBE4C5F6" }, { "id": "src-78", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "2022年移植規範", "url": "https://laws.gov.taipei/law/LawSearch/LawArticleAmend/FL076275" }, { "id": "src-79", "published_at": "2026-09-21", "source_type": "政府新聞稿", "title": "公園處說明", "url": "https://pwd.gov.taipei/News_Content.aspx?n=5C3C29C78077C93E&s=28831B7E8102EB08&sms=72544237BBE4C5F6" }, { "id": "src-80", "published_at": "", "source_type": "獨立調查報告（PDF）", "title": "運安會的獨立調查", "url": "https://www.ttsb.gov.tw/media/9561/1140303%E5%BB%A3%E6%89%BF%E6%B3%B0%E9%81%8A%E8%A6%BD%E8%BB%8A%E8%87%BA%E5%8C%97%E5%B8%82%E6%B0%91%E6%AC%8A%E6%9D%B1%E8%B7%AF%E4%BA%8C%E6%AE%B5%E5%BE%80%E6%9D%B1%E8%87%AA%E6%92%9E%E4%BA%8B%E6%95%85%E8%AA%BF%E6%9F%A5%E5%A0%B1%E5%91%8A.pdf" }, { "id": "src-81", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府網頁", "title": "兩項建議", "url": "https://www.ttsb.gov.tw/1243/22385/45199/post" }, { "id": "src-82", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府網頁", "title": "第一項", "url": "https://www.ttsb.gov.tw/1133/1154/1173/23110/49724/" }, { "id": "src-83", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府網頁", "title": "第二項", "url": "https://www.ttsb.gov.tw/1133/1154/1173/23110/49727/" }, { "id": "src-84", "published_at": "2022-05-16", "source_type": "法規（PDF）", "title": "修剪規範 PDF", "url": "https://laws.gov.taipei/law/LawSearch/LawExport/FL076333?type=2" }, { "id": "src-85", "published_at": "", "source_type": "審計報告", "title": "審核報告，工務局主管", "url": "https://auditreport.audit.gov.tw/ServerFile/Get/6388928959583828890524c17fb01e4b4aba912cd75dd879b0" }, { "id": "src-86", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "環境資訊中心", "url": "https://www.e-info.org.tw/node/243689" }, { "id": "src-87", "published_at": "", "source_type": "官方行政紀錄（PDF）", "title": "官方 2024 行政紀錄", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/001/Upload/348/relfile/31640/9138185/54c96852-6da8-4e20-acc1-5a9910f69359.pdf" }, { "id": "src-88", "published_at": "2025-12-30", "source_type": "委員會議程（PDF）", "title": "樹保會 114.12.30 幹事會議程", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=.pdf&n=44CQ5pyD6K2w6K2w56iL44CRMTE0LjEyLjMwIOiHuuWMl%2BW4guaoueacqOS%2Fneitt%2BWnlOWToeacg%2BesrDE15bGG56ysMTDmrKHlubnkuovmnIPmnIPorbDorbDnqIsucGRm&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvNjg2L3JlbGZpbGUvNTU0NzIvOTUxOTE2Ni82YjZlZGIyYy02ZDkwLTRiNjktYmZkYS04NDBhNjRjNzc5YzAucGRm" }, { "id": "src-89", "published_at": "2025-06-20", "source_type": "委員會議程（PDF）", "title": "2025/6/20 議程", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/001/Upload/544/relfile/13197/9423478/c6b0ef83-2fa4-49f9-8fe3-00c872d9fe09.pdf" }, { "id": "src-90", "published_at": "2026-09-09", "source_type": "委員會會議資料（PDF）", "title": "2026/9/9 會議資料", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvNjg2L3JlbGZpbGUvNTU0NzIvOTcwMjkzMi82NGYwNzMxZC00N2Y2LTQ0NTUtYmUxZC1hMDRkMTNjMDJlNmMucGRm&n=MC7orbDnqIvlj4rmnIPorbDos4fmlpl2Mi5wZGY%3d&icon=..pdf" }, { "id": "src-91", "published_at": "2025-05", "source_type": "議會書面答復（PDF）", "title": "市府 114 年 5 月書面答復", "url": "https://obasfront.tcc.gov.tw/Agenda/DownloadFile.aspx?FileGrpKind=1&FileName=202500001854.pdf&FilePath=202505" }, { "id": "src-92", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "工程移除要點", "url": "https://laws.gov.taipei/Law/LawSearch/LawArticleAmend/FL004004" }, { "id": "src-93", "published_at": "", "source_type": "市府新聞稿", "title": "市府新聞稿", "url": "https://www.gov.taipei/News_Content.aspx?n=F0DDAF49B89E9413&sms=72544237BBE4C5F6&s=F88DE54439B391D4" }, { "id": "src-94", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "自由時報", "url": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/life/breakingnews/5562097" }, { "id": "src-95", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府指引（PDF）", "title": "政府網站所載指引", "url": "https://www.wolverhampton.gov.uk/sites/default/files/2024-02/Forestry-Commision-Street-Trees-Duty-to-Consult-Guidance-for-Local-Authorities.pdf" }, { "id": "src-96", "published_at": "2025-03-21", "source_type": "政府公告（PDF）", "title": "巴黎市", "url": "https://cdn.paris.fr/paris/2025/03/21/programme-travaux-arbres-mis-a-jour-le-21-mars-2025-KUfV.pdf" }, { "id": "src-97", "published_at": "", "source_type": "開放資料集", "title": "移除工單", "url": "https://data.cityofnewyork.us/Environment/Forestry-Work-Orders/bdjm-n7q4" }, { "id": "src-98", "published_at": "", "source_type": "開放資料集", "title": "風險評估", "url": "https://data.cityofnewyork.us/Environment/Forestry-Risk-Assessments/259a-b6s7" }, { "id": "src-99", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府策略文件（PDF）", "title": "策略原文", "url": "https://mvga-prod-files.s3.ap-southeast-4.amazonaws.com/public/2024-07/urban-forest-strategy.pdf" }, { "id": "src-100", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規（PDF）", "title": "市政法典 813 章", "url": "https://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/municode/1184_813.pdf" }, { "id": "src-101", "published_at": "2023-04-30", "source_type": "政府新聞公報", "title": "政府新聞公報", "url": "https://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/202304/30/P2023042800374.htm" }, { "id": "src-102", "published_at": "", "source_type": "獨立調查報告（PDF）", "title": "雪菲爾獨立調查報告", "url": "https://www.sheffield.gov.uk/sites/default/files/2023-03/sheffield_street_trees_inquiry_report.pdf" }, { "id": "src-103", "published_at": "2026-10-05", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "太報 10/5", "url": "https://dev.taisounds.news/news/content/93/291501" }, { "id": "src-104", "published_at": "", "source_type": "議會案件紀錄", "title": "市議會案件紀錄", "url": "https://sfgov.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=7781521&GUID=501704C5-BB9D-4EE2-AA5F-78763BC816CC" }, { "id": "src-105", "published_at": "2026-07-08", "source_type": "市府新聞稿", "title": "市府 7/8 新聞稿", "url": "https://www.gov.taipei/News_Content.aspx?n=F0DDAF49B89E9413&sms=72544237BBE4C5F6&s=7EAA2B7A8E6EE60E" }, { "id": "src-106", "published_at": "2026-08-27", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "自由時報 8/27", "url": "https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/life/breakingnews/5553609" }, { "id": "src-107", "published_at": "", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "太報", "url": "https://dev.taisounds.news/news/content/90/291500" }, { "id": "src-108", "published_at": "2026-09-24", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "環境資訊中心 9/24", "url": "https://e-info.org.tw/node/243912" }, { "id": "src-109", "published_at": "2025-04-30", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "聯合報 2025/4/30", "url": "https://ubrand.udn.com/ubrand/story/123661/8708017" }, { "id": "src-110", "published_at": "", "source_type": "行政SOP（PDF）", "title": "解除列管流程圖", "url": "https://laws.gov.taipei/law/SOPSearch/DownloadFile?sop_no=P31000060.pdf" }, { "id": "src-111", "published_at": "2026-09-09", "source_type": "委員會會議紀錄（PDF）", "title": "樹保會 15-3 會議紀錄", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=..pdf&n=MTUtM%2BaoueS%2Fneacg%2Bacg%2BitsOe0gOmMhCjpga7nvanniYgpLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvNjg2L3JlbGZpbGUvNTU0NzIvOTcxMDU1MS9mZGJjYWY2ZS1kZTYzLTRkZWUtYjJjNS0yZmVjNGFhODNkYzUucGRm" }, { "id": "src-112", "published_at": "2011-07-12", "source_type": "法規（歷史版本）", "title": "2011年版", "url": "https://laws.gov.taipei/Law/LawSearch/LawArticleContent/FL004003?date=20110712" }, { "id": "src-113", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "2024年版", "url": "https://laws.gov.taipei/Law/LawSearch/LawArticleContent/FL004003" }, { "id": "src-114", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "工程移樹要點", "url": "https://laws.gov.taipei/Law/LawSearch/LawArticleContent/FL004004" }, { "id": "src-115", "published_at": "2026-09-16", "source_type": "委員會會議紀錄（PDF）", "title": "9月16日幹事會紀錄", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/001/Upload/686/relfile/55472/9712829/c4fdc616-0ab6-4b94-9a34-a50c1455529a.pdf" }, { "id": "src-116", "published_at": "2024-04-09", "source_type": "官方評估表彙編（PDF）", "title": "評估表彙編", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/001/Upload/405/relfile/61295/8881921/44ec43c0-d67e-4652-8da2-bc65ea3a4ecc.pdf" } ], "unknowns": [ { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "公園處或工務局公開逐年同口徑的增減原表，並說明42,250株與13,225株的算法。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-4", "e-src-15", "e-src-29" ], "id": "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-3708ce90f5ac", "question": "台北市樹木的同口徑存量帳：期初存量、種植、移除、天災、移撥與期末存量。", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "取得1150108C0006案的評鑑作業規定附件及評鑑結果原件。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-72" ], "id": "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-948df6d91d9d", "question": "服務品質評鑑作業規定：由誰評分、評哪些項目、門檻多少、是否已辦理。", "status": "bounded_unknown" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "公園處公開分項估算、逐區施工單與付款紀錄。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-4", "e-src-52", "e-src-53" ], "id": "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-848041cad1ec", "question": "多出的一億多元修剪經費，巡檢、維護型修剪與全樹型修剪各占多少，剪了哪些路段、哪些樹？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "公開富民逐樹修剪紀錄、當年契約與追責文件。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-6", "e-src-87" ], "id": "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-e81e33d33cd3", "question": "富民評估表所寫的截頂與斷頭修剪，是哪一年、由誰施作？有沒有追責？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "文化局或管理單位公開上述原件。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-1", "e-src-2", "e-src-7" ], "id": "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-6b834ae743c8", "question": "#3917的林試所檢驗報告、7/24會勘紀錄與移除核准文件。", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "議會公開9/22、10/6、10/8的審查速記錄，並載明修剪工程的處理結果。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-68", "e-src-69" ], "id": "unknown-taipei-street-tree-removal-ce389b8694b7", "question": "116年度修剪預算在議會第三輪審查的個別結果與速記錄。", "status": "world_pending" } ] }