{
  "claims": [
    {
      "boundary": "起訴人數不等於有罪人數，也不能說明滲透變多還是查得更勤；2025 年以後的數字口徑不同，不能接在這組數字後面。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-3"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-b0fa5be592a6",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "國安局統計的共諜案起訴人數（不含反滲透法案件）",
        "time": "2021–2024 年"
      },
      "status": "supported",
      "text": "國安局《共諜案滲透手法分析》列出 2021 到 2024 年共諜案起訴人數依序為 16、10、48、64 人，並註明不含《反滲透法》案件；2024 年被起訴者中現役軍人 28 人、退役軍人 15 人。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "不能把 163 人當作判決確定人數，也不能和我們整理的 29 名 2020 年後定讞者相減。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-6"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-bd66973b5379",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "國安局統計的共諜案被告（不含反滲透法案件）",
        "time": "2020 年至 2026 年 10 月報告時"
      },
      "status": "supported",
      "text": "國安局 2026 年 10 月送立法院的業務報告寫，近 7 年共諜案 179 人已經法院判決，其中有罪 163 人，定罪率 91%。報告沒有列姓名，也沒有說明「有罪」指的是哪一審。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "CB0076 只算地檢署執行的國安法案件，不是所有共諜案的總帳；它的歸類規則還沒取得，所以不能據此說政府漏算。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-7",
        "e-src-8"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-d9224bff3071",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣各地方檢察署",
        "population": "地檢署執行違反國家安全法案件的裁判確定人數",
        "time": "2022 年 1 月至 2026 年 9 月"
      },
      "status": "supported",
      "text": "法務部 CB0076 在 2022 年 1 月到 2026 年 9 月之間，逐月加總為判刑確定 64 人、無罪 13 人、免訴 3 人；判 5 年以上的只有 4 人；這份資料沒有姓名欄位。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "只能說明這一份宣導文件遮了名，不能推論檢察系統所有文件都遮名。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-10"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-f16a5ff3b1fb",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "劉聖恕案及同案被告",
        "time": "2025 年版彙編"
      },
      "status": "supported",
      "text": "最高檢察署的《2025 軍法案例宣導彙編》寫出劉聖恕案的罪名、案號，以及 2024 年 5 月 30 日 20 年確定，但被告只寫「劉○○」。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "這是有限的已知清單，不是官方母體，也不是完整名單；不含 2012 年以前、從未被報導的定讞案，也不含反滲透法案件。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-10",
        "e-src-23",
        "e-src-26",
        "e-src-27",
        "e-src-29"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-be8c919b8309",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "有可靠公開來源的共諜案有罪定讞者",
        "time": "2012 年至 2026 年 11 月 14 日"
      },
      "status": "synthesis",
      "text": "我們用公開報導和法院新聞稿逐案拼出 38 名有罪定讞者，其中 2020 年後定讞的有 29 人；孫緯、劉芸雅兩人只有部分罪名確定。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "依據是姓氏、刑期和時間都吻合；判決原件和附表遮名的對照沒有官方確認。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-26",
        "e-src-29"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-fad8a1ebc483",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "監察院附表第 13 列個案",
        "time": "2017 年定讞至 2023 年核發執行憑證"
      },
      "status": "synthesis",
      "text": "監察院調查報告附表第 13 列的「王○○」，就是 2017 年 3 月 18 年定讞的軍情局退伍少校王宗武（很可能）。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "數字截至 2025 年 1 月底，不能當成 2026 年的現況；也不能推論欠款全部出於行政怠惰。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-26"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-696cf1a14e97",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "因共諜案被判應返還退休俸的退役軍人",
        "time": "截至 2025 年 1 月 31 日"
      },
      "status": "supported",
      "text": "截至 2025 年 1 月底，因共諜案應返還退休俸的退役軍人共 19 人，應返還 7,615 萬餘元，已追回 2,538 萬餘元，還差 5,076 萬餘元。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "只說明這一案到 2025 年 1 月底的收款狀態，不能說欠款到 2026 年仍是同一個數字。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-26",
        "e-src-27",
        "e-src-28"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-538c1cb380ab",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣（新北分署執行）",
        "population": "杜永心案",
        "time": "2022 年 3 月定讞至 2025 年 1 月 31 日"
      },
      "status": "supported",
      "text": "杜永心案的追繳處分已獲最高行政法院支持；但截至 2025 年 1 月底，應返還 4,456,441 元，只追回 169,081 元，未追回 4,287,360 元。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "只描述表1 所列案件，不能推算各罪名所占比例。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-10",
        "e-src-23",
        "e-src-29"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-80f08621cce6",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "表1 所列有罪定讞者",
        "time": "2012 年至 2026 年 11 月"
      },
      "status": "synthesis",
      "text": "同樣叫「共諜」的定讞者，罪名涵蓋國安法發展組織既遂與未遂、洩漏或交付機密、交付公務上應秘密資料，以及違背職務收賄，刑期從緩刑到無期徒刑。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "不能算出刑期差異有多少來自 2019 年修法、案件類型或審理年代，也不能說刑期加重是因為法官變嚴。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-13",
        "e-src-21",
        "e-src-22"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c9290eb4be4c",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "國安法案件（監察院）；共諜案（國安局）",
        "time": "監察院統計至 2025 年上半年；國安局為 2020 年與 2026 年"
      },
      "status": "supported",
      "text": "監察院說國安法案件到 2025 年上半年平均判 31.4 個月；國安局說共諜案平均刑期從 2020 年的 1 年增加到 2026 年的 6 年 6 個月。兩者的母體不同，不能直接比較。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "無罪確定不能證明偵辦出於政治目的；何姓前幕僚目前既不是有罪，也不是無罪確定。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-16",
        "e-src-17",
        "e-src-18"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-73fc59ca1316",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "王炳忠案 5 人與何姓前幕僚",
        "time": "2022 年 8 月至 2026 年 10 月"
      },
      "status": "supported",
      "text": "王炳忠等 5 人 2022 年 8 月無罪確定；何姓前幕僚一審判 8 年 2 月、二審改判無罪，2026 年 10 月被最高法院撤銷發回，目前仍未確定。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "到 2026 年 11 月，我們沒找到更審判決，發回的三人不列為定讞者。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-1",
        "e-src-2"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8f5344041c17",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "丁小琥案被告",
        "time": "2026 年 2 月至 2026 年 11 月"
      },
      "status": "supported",
      "text": "2026 年 7 月，丁小琥案有三人定讞、三名軍官被發回更審；丁小琥本人已在 2026 年 2 月病逝，法院判公訴不受理。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "只以找得到的公開紀錄判斷進度；不能說恢復軍審後判決會比較重。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-30"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-0c76757ed810",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "現役軍人軍事犯罪的審判制度",
        "time": "2025 年 3 月至 2026 年 11 月"
      },
      "status": "partially_supported",
      "text": "總統府 2025 年 3 月 13 日宣布，現役軍人觸犯軍事犯罪將交軍事法院審判；以我們找得到的公開紀錄為準，到 2026 年 11 月仍未完成立法。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "這是起訴指控與官方社論，不能推估有多少共諜案源自債務脅迫。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-3",
        "e-src-14",
        "e-src-15"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7465be4a8525",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "台灣",
        "population": "國安局歸納的案件與高雄高分檢起訴的個案",
        "time": "2024–2025 年"
      },
      "status": "supported",
      "text": "檢方起訴的案件裡，有被告對欠債的軍士官威脅要向部隊告發，逼他們蒐集情資；青年日報社論也承認，有官兵急用時求助無門。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "這些只是選例，不代表兩國所有案件；也不能說點名公開能減少間諜案。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-32",
        "e-src-34"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8a4209611cca",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "愛沙尼亞、美國",
        "population": "兩國公開的間諜案判刑者",
        "time": "KAPO 2024–2025 年報；美國 2021 年 Debbins 案"
      },
      "status": "supported",
      "text": "愛沙尼亞 KAPO 的年度報告寫出被判刑者的全名和刑期，連判決尚未生效的人也寫；美國司法部則逐案發出具名新聞稿。"
    },
    {
      "boundary": "目前只有官方說明的目的和評論者的肯定，我們沒找到獨立的效果研究。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-31",
        "e-src-32",
        "e-src-33"
      ],
      "id": "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-e1366cb5c205",
      "scope": {
        "geography": "愛沙尼亞",
        "population": "KAPO 公開點名的做法",
        "time": "2024–2025 年"
      },
      "status": "not_established",
      "text": "點名公開能減少間諜案。"
    }
  ],
  "evidence": [
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7441b0439d8c"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-1",
      "locator": "2026-07-02 報導：共諜案三人定讞（王文豪 7 年、譚俊明 7 年 2 月、呂芳契 6 年），同案另三名軍官由最高法院發回更審",
      "source_id": "src-1",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8f5344041c17"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-2",
      "locator": "報導段落：丁小琥 2026 年 2 月病逝，法院判公訴不受理",
      "source_id": "src-2",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8f5344041c17"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-3",
      "locator": "國安局《共諜案滲透手法分析》：2021–2024 年共諜案起訴人數／件數統計、「不含《反滲透法》案件」附註、2024 年現役 28 人與退役 15 人",
      "source_id": "src-3",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7465be4a8525",
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-b0fa5be592a6"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-4",
      "locator": "國安局業務報告 p.11：2025 年 1–9 月共諜案起訴 24 人",
      "source_id": "src-4",
      "supports": []
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-5",
      "locator": "國安局業務報告 p.12：2025 年至 2026 年 3 月共諜案起訴 58 人",
      "source_id": "src-5",
      "supports": []
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-733fb59f029d"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-6",
      "locator": "國安局業務報告 p.12：近 7 年共諜案起訴人數（2020 年 6 人至 2026 年 73 人）；179 人經判決、有罪 163 人、定罪率 91%",
      "source_id": "src-6",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-bd66973b5379"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c161d27a03b3"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-7",
      "locator": "資料集 130162「地方檢察署執行違反國家安全法案件裁判確定人數」；欄位：刑名、性別、年月、人數（每月更新）",
      "source_id": "src-7",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-d9224bff3071"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c161d27a03b3"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-8",
      "locator": "開放資料 CB0076：2022 年 1 月至 2026 年 9 月逐月資料；刑名欄（含「七年以上十年未滿」「逾十五年」）、無罪、免訴人數",
      "source_id": "src-8",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-d9224bff3071"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-9",
      "locator": "刑事訴訟法第 457 條",
      "source_id": "src-9",
      "supports": []
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7441b0439d8c"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-10",
      "locator": "《2025 軍法案例宣導彙編》劉聖恕案檢討：p.77 註4（修正條文「處七年以上有期徒刑」）、p.78（同案孫姓退役中校 8 年、劉姓少校 9 年）；最高法院 113 年度台上字第 336 號",
      "source_id": "src-10",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-80f08621cce6",
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-be8c919b8309",
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-f16a5ff3b1fb"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1c9cc4110617"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-11",
      "locator": "台灣安保協會「共諜案紀年」頁面（2021 年以後案件；自註非官方、非完整清單）",
      "source_id": "src-11",
      "supports": []
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1c9cc4110617"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-12",
      "locator": "維基百科條目「中華民國國軍中的中共間諜列表」",
      "source_id": "src-12",
      "supports": []
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-13",
      "locator": "司法院書面報告：發展組織罪 2019 年修法前（5 年以下）與修法後（7 年以上）刑度對照段落",
      "source_id": "src-13",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c9290eb4be4c"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-14",
      "locator": "報導段落：高雄高分檢 2025 年起訴案，被告威脅欠債軍士官向部隊告發以蒐集情資",
      "source_id": "src-14",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7465be4a8525"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-15",
      "locator": "青年日報社論：官兵急用時求助無門而落入陷阱段落",
      "source_id": "src-15",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7465be4a8525"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-16",
      "locator": "台北地院一審判決新聞稿：何姓前幕僚判 8 年 2 月（2025 年 9 月）",
      "source_id": "src-16",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-73fc59ca1316"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7441b0439d8c"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-17",
      "locator": "2026-10-29 報導：最高法院撤銷何姓前幕僚無罪判決、黃姓前特助有罪部分一併發回更審",
      "source_id": "src-17",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-73fc59ca1316"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-18",
      "locator": "2022-08-05 報導：王炳忠等 5 人國安法案無罪確定",
      "source_id": "src-18",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-73fc59ca1316"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-19",
      "locator": "評論文章：王炳忠案支持者稱統派因此受傷段落",
      "source_id": "src-19",
      "supports": []
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-20",
      "locator": "報導：司改會 2026 年 1 月批評某共諜案偵查細節外流、未審先判",
      "source_id": "src-20",
      "supports": []
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-21",
      "locator": "監察院新聞稿：違反國家安全法案件至 2025 年上半年平均判 31.4 個月、委員認為存在輕判",
      "source_id": "src-21",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c9290eb4be4c"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-22",
      "locator": "2026-10-20 報導：國安局稱共諜案平均刑期由 2020 年 1 年增至 2026 年 6 年 6 個月",
      "source_id": "src-22",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c9290eb4be4c"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-23",
      "locator": "2025-12-03 報導：張超然 1 年 6 月、周天慈 1 年 2 月、岳志忠 10 月定讞",
      "source_id": "src-23",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-80f08621cce6",
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-be8c919b8309"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-24",
      "locator": "國家安全法第 13 條（喪失退休給與、已領者追繳、自犯罪時起算）",
      "source_id": "src-24",
      "supports": []
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-25",
      "locator": "2024-06-05 報導：退輔會稱 15 人須追繳，7 人繳清、8 人移送行政執行",
      "source_id": "src-25",
      "supports": []
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1c9cc4110617",
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1e778233414f",
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-ba995bc71779"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-26",
      "locator": "監察院調查報告 p.3（截至 2025 年 1 月底 19 人應返還退休俸、9 人繳清、10 人移送行政執行署）；附表 p.13–14 第6列（杜○○）、p.15–16 第13列（王○○）",
      "source_id": "src-26",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-538c1cb380ab",
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-696cf1a14e97",
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-be8c919b8309",
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-fad8a1ebc483"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1e778233414f"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-27",
      "locator": "2024-06-03 報導：最高行政法院駁回杜永心退休金追討案上訴",
      "source_id": "src-27",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-538c1cb380ab",
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-be8c919b8309"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-28",
      "locator": "憲法法庭裁定 p.1：杜永心案上訴審案號",
      "source_id": "src-28",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-538c1cb380ab"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-29",
      "locator": "2017-04-01 報導：最高法院 106 年度台上字第 286 號駁回上訴、18 年確定",
      "source_id": "src-29",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-80f08621cce6",
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-be8c919b8309",
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-fad8a1ebc483"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-45ed0bca531f"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-30",
      "locator": "總統府新聞稿：2025 年 3 月 13 日宣布現役軍人觸犯軍事犯罪交軍事法院審判",
      "source_id": "src-30",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-0c76757ed810"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7e9ffb8f5dff"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-31",
      "locator": "報導段落：KAPO 每年於年度報告點名公開查獲之敵方人員",
      "source_id": "src-31",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-e1366cb5c205"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7e9ffb8f5dff"
      ],
      "id": "e-src-32",
      "locator": "KAPO Annual Review 2024–2025：p.26（GRU 人員判 6 年 6 個月）、p.30–31（塔爾圖大學俄籍講師判 6 年 3 個月）；2024 年公開網攻案段落",
      "source_id": "src-32",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8a4209611cca",
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-e1366cb5c205"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-33",
      "locator": "Kaja Kallas 維也納言論自由演講：「最好的疫苗是公開談論」段落",
      "source_id": "src-33",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-e1366cb5c205"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [],
      "id": "e-src-34",
      "locator": "美國司法部新聞稿：前綠扁帽 Peter Debbins 因俄國間諜共謀判 188 個月",
      "source_id": "src-34",
      "supports": [
        "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8a4209611cca"
      ]
    },
    {
      "bounds_unknowns": [
        "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-364351dc2d8d"
      ],
      "id": "e-page",
      "locator": "頁面「還不知道、而且會改變結論的」區段",
      "source_id": "src-page",
      "supports": []
    }
  ],
  "inquiry": {
    "id": "pursuit_a52a937b29d689ec712a",
    "reader_promise": "我們從新聞和法院新聞稿拼出2020年後29名定讞者；本篇核對的國安局報告與CB0076統計未列姓名，最高檢彙編的劉聖恕案則遮名。",
    "root_question": "台灣共諜名單在哪裡？國安局說 2020 年後 163 人有罪，姓名與定讞結果得逐案拼接",
    "updated_at": "2026-11-14T07:08:03+00:00"
  },
  "queries": [
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-b0fa5be592a6",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-bd66973b5379",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-d9224bff3071",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-f16a5ff3b1fb",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-be8c919b8309",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-fad8a1ebc483",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-696cf1a14e97",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-538c1cb380ab",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-80f08621cce6",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c9290eb4be4c",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-73fc59ca1316",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8f5344041c17",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-0c76757ed810",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7465be4a8525",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8a4209611cca",
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-e1366cb5c205"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": [
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-733fb59f029d",
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c161d27a03b3",
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1c9cc4110617",
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7441b0439d8c",
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-ba995bc71779",
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1e778233414f",
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-45ed0bca531f",
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-364351dc2d8d",
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7e9ffb8f5dff"
        ]
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-a857340435e1",
      "text": "台灣共諜名單在哪裡？國安局說 2020 年後 163 人有罪，姓名與定讞結果得逐案拼接"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-b0fa5be592a6"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-b0fa5be592a6",
      "text": "國安局《共諜案滲透手法分析》列出 2021 到 2024 年共諜案起訴人數依序為 16、10、48、64 人，並註明不含《反滲透法》案件；2024 年被起訴者中現役軍人 28 人、退役軍人 15 人。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-bd66973b5379"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-bd66973b5379",
      "text": "國安局 2026 年 10 月送立法院的業務報告寫，近 7 年共諜案 179 人已經法院判決，其中有罪 163 人，定罪率 91%。報告沒有列姓名，也沒有說明「有罪」指的是哪一審。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-d9224bff3071"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-d9224bff3071",
      "text": "法務部 CB0076 在 2022 年 1 月到 2026 年 9 月之間，逐月加總為判刑確定 64 人、無罪 13 人、免訴 3 人；判 5 年以上的只有 4 人；這份資料沒有姓名欄位。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-f16a5ff3b1fb"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-f16a5ff3b1fb",
      "text": "最高檢察署的《2025 軍法案例宣導彙編》寫出劉聖恕案的罪名、案號，以及 2024 年 5 月 30 日 20 年確定，但被告只寫「劉○○」。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-be8c919b8309"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-be8c919b8309",
      "text": "我們用公開報導和法院新聞稿逐案拼出 38 名有罪定讞者，其中 2020 年後定讞的有 29 人；孫緯、劉芸雅兩人只有部分罪名確定。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-fad8a1ebc483"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-fad8a1ebc483",
      "text": "監察院調查報告附表第 13 列的「王○○」，就是 2017 年 3 月 18 年定讞的軍情局退伍少校王宗武（很可能）。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-696cf1a14e97"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-696cf1a14e97",
      "text": "截至 2025 年 1 月底，因共諜案應返還退休俸的退役軍人共 19 人，應返還 7,615 萬餘元，已追回 2,538 萬餘元，還差 5,076 萬餘元。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-538c1cb380ab"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-538c1cb380ab",
      "text": "杜永心案的追繳處分已獲最高行政法院支持；但截至 2025 年 1 月底，應返還 4,456,441 元，只追回 169,081 元，未追回 4,287,360 元。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-80f08621cce6"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-80f08621cce6",
      "text": "同樣叫「共諜」的定讞者，罪名涵蓋國安法發展組織既遂與未遂、洩漏或交付機密、交付公務上應秘密資料，以及違背職務收賄，刑期從緩刑到無期徒刑。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c9290eb4be4c"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c9290eb4be4c",
      "text": "監察院說國安法案件到 2025 年上半年平均判 31.4 個月；國安局說共諜案平均刑期從 2020 年的 1 年增加到 2026 年的 6 年 6 個月。兩者的母體不同，不能直接比較。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-73fc59ca1316"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-73fc59ca1316",
      "text": "王炳忠等 5 人 2022 年 8 月無罪確定；何姓前幕僚一審判 8 年 2 月、二審改判無罪，2026 年 10 月被最高法院撤銷發回，目前仍未確定。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8f5344041c17"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8f5344041c17",
      "text": "2026 年 7 月，丁小琥案有三人定讞、三名軍官被發回更審；丁小琥本人已在 2026 年 2 月病逝，法院判公訴不受理。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-0c76757ed810"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-0c76757ed810",
      "text": "總統府 2025 年 3 月 13 日宣布，現役軍人觸犯軍事犯罪將交軍事法院審判；以我們找得到的公開紀錄為準，到 2026 年 11 月仍未完成立法。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7465be4a8525"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7465be4a8525",
      "text": "檢方起訴的案件裡，有被告對欠債的軍士官威脅要向部隊告發，逼他們蒐集情資；青年日報社論也承認，有官兵急用時求助無門。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8a4209611cca"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-8a4209611cca",
      "text": "愛沙尼亞 KAPO 的年度報告寫出被判刑者的全名和刑期，連判決尚未生效的人也寫；美國司法部則逐案發出具名新聞稿。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [
          "claim-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-e1366cb5c205"
        ],
        "unknown_ids": []
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-e1366cb5c205",
      "text": "點名公開能減少間諜案。"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [],
        "unknown_ids": [
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-733fb59f029d"
        ]
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-733fb59f029d",
      "text": "國安局說的 163 人「有罪」，是一審有罪還是判決確定？同一人在不同審級有沒有重複計算？"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [],
        "unknown_ids": [
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c161d27a03b3"
        ]
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c161d27a03b3",
      "text": "CB0076 的裁判確定人數怎麼計算：主要罪名、多罪併罰與執行機關各怎麼歸類？"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [],
        "unknown_ids": [
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1c9cc4110617"
        ]
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1c9cc4110617",
      "text": "2012 年以前，以及從未被報導的有罪定讞共諜案有哪些？"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [],
        "unknown_ids": [
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7441b0439d8c"
        ]
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7441b0439d8c",
      "text": "丁小琥案三名發回軍官、孫緯夫妻其餘罪名、何姓前幕僚等人，以及許氏兄弟案，最後的判決結果是什麼？"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [],
        "unknown_ids": [
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-ba995bc71779"
        ]
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-ba995bc71779",
      "text": "行政院有沒有照監察院的意見，督促各機關在起訴或一審時先聲請假扣押其他財產？"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [],
        "unknown_ids": [
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1e778233414f"
        ]
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1e778233414f",
      "text": "杜永心案在 2025 年 1 月底以後，新北分署有沒有再收到款項？"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [],
        "unknown_ids": [
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-45ed0bca531f"
        ]
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-45ed0bca531f",
      "text": "軍審四法什麼時候送進立法院、什麼時候完成立法？"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [],
        "unknown_ids": [
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-364351dc2d8d"
        ]
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-364351dc2d8d",
      "text": "負債軍人與軍眷怎麼描述債務壓力和求助管道？"
    },
    {
      "expects": {
        "claim_ids": [],
        "unknown_ids": [
          "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7e9ffb8f5dff"
        ]
      },
      "id": "query-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7e9ffb8f5dff",
      "text": "像愛沙尼亞那樣點名公開，真的能減少間諜案或提高防護嗎？"
    }
  ],
  "schema": "walkingbook-public-knowledge-v0",
  "source": {
    "path": "docs/product/evidence/walkingbook-question-93bf802cfcb69224-editorial-review.md",
    "sha256": "097a12fdbe3fd99dabdd63374766d68846c43fe555fa9d4026a2b892f9c504ee"
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "src-1",
      "published_at": "2026-07-02",
      "source_type": "新聞報導",
      "title": "最高法院發回更審",
      "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/asoc/202607020076.aspx"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-2",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "新聞報導",
      "title": "病逝，法院判公訴不受理",
      "url": "https://news.pts.org.tw/article/803756"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-3",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "政府機關新聞稿／分析報告",
      "title": "不含涉及《反滲透法》的案件",
      "url": "https://www.nsb.gov.tw/zh/assets/documents/%E6%96%B0%E8%81%9E%E7%A8%BF/ed8fddb8-3d99-4d3f-9414-c9b360f2df5a.pdf"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-4",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "立法院議事附件（國安局業務報告）",
      "title": "起訴 24 人",
      "url": "https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/SittingAttachment/download/2025100916/04205200426011122003.pdf"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-5",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "立法院議事附件（國安局業務報告）",
      "title": "起訴 58 人",
      "url": "https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/SittingAttachment/download/2026033105/84201600173026605003.pdf"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-6",
      "published_at": "2026-10",
      "source_type": "立法院議事附件（國安局業務報告）",
      "title": "送立法院的業務報告",
      "url": "https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/SittingAttachment/download/2026101538/48240116052259210002.pdf"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-7",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "政府開放資料集",
      "title": "地方檢察署執行違反國家安全法案件裁判確定人數",
      "url": "https://data.gov.tw/dataset/130162"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-8",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "政府開放資料（法務部統計）",
      "title": "這份資料",
      "url": "https://www.rjsd.moj.gov.tw/rjsdweb/OpenData.ashx?code=CB0076"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-9",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "法規條文",
      "title": "刑事訴訟法第457條",
      "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawSingle.aspx?flno=457&pcode=C0010001"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-10",
      "published_at": "2025",
      "source_type": "檢察機關出版品（案例彙編）",
      "title": "2025 軍法案例宣導彙編",
      "url": "https://www.tps.moj.gov.tw/media/403727/%E7%AC%AC%E4%BA%8C%E5%86%8A-%E7%B6%A0-_%E8%BB%8D%E6%B3%95%E6%A1%88%E4%BE%8B%E5%AE%A3%E5%B0%8E%E5%BD%99%E7%B7%A8_04-2-1.pdf?mediaDL=true"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-11",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "民間整理資料",
      "title": "共諜案紀年",
      "url": "https://cnthreats.report/zh-hant/espionage-timeline"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-12",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "維基百科條目",
      "title": "國軍中的中共間諜列表",
      "url": "https://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E4%B8%AD%E8%8F%AF%E6%B0%91%E5%9C%8B%E5%9C%8B%E8%BB%8D%E4%B8%AD%E7%9A%84%E4%B8%AD%E5%85%B1%E9%96%93%E8%AB%9C%E5%88%97%E8%A1%A8"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-13",
      "published_at": "2025-04",
      "source_type": "立法院議事附件（司法院書面報告）",
      "title": "司法院書面報告",
      "url": "https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/SittingAttachment/download/2025041794/00024082521183104002.pdf"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-14",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "新聞報導",
      "title": "威脅要向部隊告發",
      "url": "https://www.nownews.com/amp/news/6642802"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-15",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "社論（國防部青年日報）",
      "title": "求助無門",
      "url": "https://www.ydn.com.tw/tw/News/ugC_News_Detail.aspx?ID=624023"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-16",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "法院新聞稿",
      "title": "台北地院一審",
      "url": "https://www.judicial.gov.tw/tw/cp-1888-1411948-22fee-1.html"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-17",
      "published_at": "2026-10-29",
      "source_type": "新聞報導",
      "title": "發回更審",
      "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/asoc/202610290293.aspx"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-18",
      "published_at": "2022-08-05",
      "source_type": "新聞報導",
      "title": "無罪確定",
      "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/asoc/202208050067.aspx"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-19",
      "published_at": "2024-01-02",
      "source_type": "評論文章（支持者觀點）",
      "title": "統派因此受傷",
      "url": "https://rise-tw.org/2024/01/02/綠營又出奧步%EF%BC%8C%E7%B5%B1%E6%B4%BE%E6%88%90%E7%8A%A7%E7%89%B2%E5%93%81-%E9%83%AD%E8%AD%BD%E7%94%B3/"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-20",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "公民媒體報導",
      "title": "未審先判",
      "url": "https://www.civilmedia.tw/archives/137459"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-21",
      "published_at": "2026-03",
      "source_type": "監察院新聞稿",
      "title": "平均判 31.4 個月",
      "url": "https://multimedia.cy.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=125&s=37034"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-22",
      "published_at": "2026-10-20",
      "source_type": "新聞報導",
      "title": "增加到 2026 年的 6 年 6 個月",
      "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aipl/202610200201.aspx"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-23",
      "published_at": "2025-12-03",
      "source_type": "新聞報導",
      "title": "張超然、周天慈、岳志忠",
      "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/asoc/202512030195.aspx"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-24",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "法規條文",
      "title": "喪失退休給與，已領的要追繳",
      "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawSingle.aspx?flno=13&pcode=A0030028"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-25",
      "published_at": "2024-06-05",
      "source_type": "新聞報導",
      "title": "7 人繳清、8 人移送行政執行",
      "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aipl/202406050159.aspx"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-26",
      "published_at": "2025-04",
      "source_type": "監察院調查報告",
      "title": "調查報告",
      "url": "https://cybsbox.cy.gov.tw/CYBSBoxSSL/edoc/download/69608"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-27",
      "published_at": "2024-06-03",
      "source_type": "新聞報導",
      "title": "駁回上訴",
      "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/asoc/202406030054.aspx"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-28",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "憲法法庭裁定",
      "title": "憲法法庭裁定",
      "url": "https://cons.judicial.gov.tw/download/download.aspx?id=433541"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-29",
      "published_at": "2017-04-01",
      "source_type": "新聞報導",
      "title": "中央社報導",
      "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/firstnews/201704010133.aspx"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-30",
      "published_at": "2025-03-13",
      "source_type": "總統府新聞稿",
      "title": "將交軍事法院審判",
      "url": "https://www.president.gov.tw/News/39105"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-31",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "新聞報導（外媒）",
      "title": "點名公開",
      "url": "https://www.thedailybeast.com/estonia-the-little-spycatcher-who-could/"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-32",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "政府機關年度報告",
      "title": "2024–2025 年版",
      "url": "https://kapo.ee/sites/default/files/content_page_attachments/annual-review-2024-2025.pdf"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-33",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "政府演講稿",
      "title": "最好的疫苗是公開談論",
      "url": "https://valitsus.ee/en/news/speech-freedom-prime-minister-kaja-kallas-vienna-8022024"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-34",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "政府新聞稿（美國司法部，封存）",
      "title": "188 個月",
      "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/former-army-green-beret-sentenced-russian-espionage-conspiracy"
    },
    {
      "id": "src-page",
      "published_at": "",
      "source_type": "walkingbook_public_page",
      "title": "台灣共諜名單在哪裡？國安局說 2020 年後 163 人有罪，姓名與定讞結果得逐案拼接",
      "url": "https://walkingbook.tw/inquiry/taiwan-espionage-convictions-list/"
    }
  ],
  "unknowns": [
    {
      "changes_claim_ids": [],
      "closure": "國安局公開說明 163 人的審級定義與計算方式，或提供逐案的審級與確定日期。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-6"
      ],
      "id": "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-733fb59f029d",
      "question": "國安局說的 163 人「有罪」，是一審有罪還是判決確定？同一人在不同審級有沒有重複計算？",
      "status": "not_requested"
    },
    {
      "changes_claim_ids": [],
      "closure": "取得法務部「統計用詞解釋」中國安法裁判確定人數的完整定義頁，或法務部提供逐案對照。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-7",
        "e-src-8"
      ],
      "id": "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-c161d27a03b3",
      "question": "CB0076 的裁判確定人數怎麼計算：主要罪名、多罪併罰與執行機關各怎麼歸類？",
      "status": "public_not_found"
    },
    {
      "changes_claim_ids": [],
      "closure": "取得官方具名的定讞清單；或用監察院附表其他遮名列（例如第 3、4 列）的案號逐一查出公開姓名。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-11",
        "e-src-12",
        "e-src-26"
      ],
      "id": "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1c9cc4110617",
      "question": "2012 年以前，以及從未被報導的有罪定讞共諜案有哪些？",
      "status": "bounded_unknown"
    },
    {
      "changes_claim_ids": [],
      "closure": "各案更審或上訴審判決確定，並有法院新聞稿或判決書可查。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-1",
        "e-src-10",
        "e-src-17"
      ],
      "id": "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7441b0439d8c",
      "question": "丁小琥案三名發回軍官、孫緯夫妻其餘罪名、何姓前幕僚等人，以及許氏兄弟案，最後的判決結果是什麼？",
      "status": "world_pending"
    },
    {
      "changes_claim_ids": [],
      "closure": "行政院對監察院調查報告的公開函復，或相關修法與行政規則的公開紀錄。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-26"
      ],
      "id": "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-ba995bc71779",
      "question": "行政院有沒有照監察院的意見，督促各機關在起訴或一審時先聲請假扣押其他財產？",
      "status": "public_not_found"
    },
    {
      "changes_claim_ids": [],
      "closure": "監察院後續追蹤報告，或法務部行政執行署公開的執行結果。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-26",
        "e-src-27"
      ],
      "id": "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-1e778233414f",
      "question": "杜永心案在 2025 年 1 月底以後，新北分署有沒有再收到款項？",
      "status": "public_not_found"
    },
    {
      "changes_claim_ids": [],
      "closure": "行政院通過軍審四法草案並函送立法院的公開紀錄，或立法院三讀紀錄。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-30"
      ],
      "id": "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-45ed0bca531f",
      "question": "軍審四法什麼時候送進立法院、什麼時候完成立法？",
      "status": "world_pending"
    },
    {
      "changes_claim_ids": [],
      "closure": "找到可核實身分的軍眷或負債軍人的第一手公開說法。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-page"
      ],
      "id": "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-364351dc2d8d",
      "question": "負債軍人與軍眷怎麼描述債務壓力和求助管道？",
      "status": "public_not_found"
    },
    {
      "changes_claim_ids": [],
      "closure": "找到獨立評估點名公開效果的研究或官方評估報告。",
      "evidence_refs": [
        "e-src-31",
        "e-src-32"
      ],
      "id": "unknown-taiwan-espionage-convictions-list-7e9ffb8f5dff",
      "question": "像愛沙尼亞那樣點名公開，真的能減少間諜案或提高防護嗎？",
      "status": "public_not_found"
    }
  ]
}