{ "claims": [ { "boundary": "只是會前會裁示，不代表各案後來有沒有執行，也不能外推到其他屆。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-11" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-54392eb7c842", "scope": { "geography": "桃園市", "population": "桃園市第六屆青年諮詢委員會的19件提案", "time": "2025年11月10日會前會" }, "status": "supported", "text": "桃園第六屆青諮會2025年11月10日的會前會逐案討論19案，主席裁示：納入參採6案、部分參採10案、暫未參採2案、提請市長裁示1案。" }, { "boundary": "「至少7案」是我們根據會議紀錄的文字分類，不是市府的官方統計。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-11" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-723e9e96255f", "scope": { "geography": "桃園市", "population": "第六屆會前會19案", "time": "2025年11月" }, "status": "supported", "text": "依我們逐案分類，19案裡至少7案的局處回應指向既有業務。例如AI抓噪音車，環保局原本就已經在用13套AI設備，這案仍被列為「納入參採」。" }, { "boundary": "國際展望組的提案網站自述不是市府官方網站，只代表那一組的紀錄。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-11", "e-src-12" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9b5907c0f4b0", "scope": { "geography": "桃園市", "population": "桃園市第六、七屆青諮委員及青年局", "time": "2025年11月至2026年" }, "status": "supported", "text": "桃園青年局長在會前會開場說，市長多次希望各組在正式會議前先討論、調整題目，以「降低不參採比例」。第七屆有一組委員的提案網站記錄，提案被「改寫為『政績語言』」，對接既有KPI。" }, { "boundary": "2026年3月之後的工作報告我們沒有取得。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-11", "e-src-18", "e-src-19" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-c720d1e44e97", "scope": { "geography": "桃園市", "population": "桃園市青年事務局與青諮委員", "time": "2025年11月至2026年5月" }, "status": "supported", "text": "桃園青年局2025年說會持續向局處追蹤各提案，但2026年3月向議會的工作報告只寫「共決議參採17項青年政策建議」，沒有逐案進度和主責局處。2026年5月第七屆委員再次建議追蹤歷屆提案。" }, { "boundary": "這是官員的口頭答詢，沒有逐次出席紀錄。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-25" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-3e16f0251c83", "scope": { "geography": "台北市", "population": "台北市青年事務委員會大會", "time": "新制成立至2026年7月24日" }, "status": "supported", "text": "台北市青年事務委員會成立以來開過6次大會，主任委員是市長，市長只出席過1次。這是青年局主任秘書2026年7月在議會的答詢。" }, { "boundary": "只核到第5到第7次會議紀錄，不能推論所有列管案都這樣結案。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-22", "e-src-23", "e-src-24" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-b4eea2cf39b5", "scope": { "geography": "台北市", "population": "台北市青年事務委員會列管提案", "time": "2026年3月至9月" }, "status": "supported", "text": "台北青委會會以「已配合規劃課程」「已完成示範點改善」「已確立宣導標語」這類理由解除提案列管，紀錄上沒有地點、數量或成效。" }, { "boundary": "時間和內容接得上，但簡章沒有提到青諮會，也沒有行政紀錄證明是青諮促成立案。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-11", "e-src-13", "e-src-14" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-130c02ac56e3", "scope": { "geography": "桃園市", "population": "桃園市青年事務局辦理的青年辯論賽", "time": "2025年11月至2026年8月" }, "status": "partially_supported", "text": "青年辯論賽是委員2025年11月建議市府主辦的，主席裁示2026年試辦，2026年8月底青年盃辯論賽落幕，共16隊參賽。" }, { "boundary": "第7、8選區的公報是掃描圖檔，有少數字跡辨識不全。這只能量到參選公報這一種用途，量不到升學、求職、黨職或幕僚。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-32", "e-src-35" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-d0a26da27d42", "scope": { "geography": "桃園市", "population": "2022年桃園市議員候選人131人", "time": "2022年市議員選舉" }, "status": "supported", "text": "2022年桃園市議員選舉14個選區、131位候選人中，選舉公報經歷欄寫了青諮的只有張碩芳一人。" }, { "boundary": "這不是全年出席紀錄，其他小組的紀錄也沒有讀，不能推論他沒參與。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-11", "e-src-34" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-47d0a4f6e90e", "scope": { "geography": "桃園市", "population": "第六屆青諮委員佀廣洋", "time": "第六屆（2025–2026年）" }, "status": "supported", "text": "在我們讀到的第六屆六份公開紀錄裡（會前會、成立大會紀實、四個小組第一次會議），沒有看到佀廣洋具名提案或發言。" }, { "boundary": "我們沒有找到因為批評市府被解聘的公開案例。桃園第七屆切結書的原件也沒有取得。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-38", "e-src-39", "e-src-40", "e-src-41" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-8cbbf8fb0d77", "scope": { "geography": "桃園市、台北市、台中市", "population": "三市青諮委員", "time": "各市現行與近屆" }, "status": "supported", "text": "桃園第六屆切結書要求委員「應適時宣傳或支援本府各項政策」，委員若「有損害本府聲譽之情事」得被解聘。台北、台中也有類似的聲譽條款，台北第二屆還把「各項公眾發言」列為解聘與下屆遴選的參據。" }, { "boundary": "修規後的準時回覆率和成效，我們沒有查到。2021年審計批評的是修規前的情況。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-26", "e-src-27" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-f60dc5ee778c", "scope": { "geography": "芬蘭赫爾辛基", "population": "13至17歲居民提出的青年提案", "time": "2023年修規後" }, "status": "supported", "text": "赫爾辛基2023年修正行政規則，青年提案由有權限的委員會回覆，屬市議會或市政府權限的由市長回覆，市府目標是三個月內回覆。" }, { "boundary": "這是質性訪談，不能推論桃園或台北每一屆都這樣選人。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-37" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-feee8ee3bf0e", "scope": { "geography": "台灣各級政府", "population": "15位青諮召集人、委員與承辦公務員", "time": "研究訪談期間" }, "status": "partially_supported", "text": "一篇訪談15位各級青諮相關人員的研究指出，縣市政府徵選時「會傾向意見相近或較無強勢意見之青年」。" }, { "boundary": "這是我們綜合公開證據的判斷，把握是「很可能」。如果逐案紀錄顯示提案改變了市府原定做法，這個判斷就要改。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-11", "e-src-18", "e-src-22", "e-src-25", "e-src-31" ], "id": "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9cd246ba4572", "scope": { "geography": "桃園市為主，台北市對照", "population": "兩市青年諮詢組織", "time": "2015年至2026年" }, "status": "synthesis", "text": "十年下來，青諮會有開會也有活動，但市府只數得出參採幾案，數不出青年改變了什麼，也說不清委員是怎麼選進去的。" } ], "evidence": [ { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-94f546bdc81a" ], "id": "e-src-1", "locator": "2026/10/24 報導：桃園市議員參選人質疑兩位立委之子曾任青年諮詢委員，並要求青年局公開報名經歷與評分", "source_id": "src-1", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-94f546bdc81a" ], "id": "e-src-2", "locator": "2026/10/24 報導：青年局回應遴選「依照公開遴選簡章及既定程序辦理」", "source_id": "src-2", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-3", "locator": "2026/7/6 報導：佀廣洋因校園霸凌等指控公開致歉", "source_id": "src-3", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-4", "locator": "2026/9/3 報導：佀廣洋以無黨籍登記參選市議員", "source_id": "src-4", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-5", "locator": "2015/9/1 新聞稿：台北市青年事務委員會成立、10 位青年代表、柯文哲致詞", "source_id": "src-5", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-6", "locator": "2016/3/22 報導：鄭文燦稱「青年諮詢委員會就是青年市議會」", "source_id": "src-6", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-7", "locator": "2016/3/29 報導：桃園首屆青諮會成立、聘 29 位委員", "source_id": "src-7", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-8", "locator": "2016/3/29 報導：桃園首屆青諮會成立、聘 29 位委員", "source_id": "src-8", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-9", "locator": "p.1（設置目的）", "source_id": "src-9", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-10", "locator": "《青年基本法》全文：「各級政府應設置青年諮詢組織」條文", "source_id": "src-10", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-6296c42c98f0" ], "id": "e-src-11", "locator": "第六屆會前會紀錄（2025/11/10）：19 案局處回應與主席裁示；辯論賽案 p.17", "source_id": "src-11", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-130c02ac56e3", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-47d0a4f6e90e", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-54392eb7c842", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-723e9e96255f", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9b5907c0f4b0", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9cd246ba4572", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-c720d1e44e97" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-12", "locator": "/proposal 頁：導師建議對接局處績效指標、改寫為「政績語言」、「新增計畫 → 對接既有 KPI」", "source_id": "src-12", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9b5907c0f4b0" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-6296c42c98f0" ], "id": "e-src-13", "locator": "2026/7/4 新聞：青年盃辯論賽", "source_id": "src-13", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-130c02ac56e3" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-14", "locator": "2026 年 8 月底賽事成果報導：青年盃辯論賽落幕、16 隊參賽", "source_id": "src-14", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-130c02ac56e3" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-6296c42c98f0" ], "id": "e-src-15", "locator": "p.4（參與式預算、總經費 40 萬元）；p.21–22（「青年下班解憂所」約 30 萬元、外籍人士交通宣導影片初估 20 萬元）", "source_id": "src-15", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-6296c42c98f0" ], "id": "e-src-16", "locator": "網站首頁自述（將對話整理成政策建議給青年局參考）", "source_id": "src-16", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-17", "locator": "p.5（第六屆委員呂承宗發言）", "source_id": "src-17", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-6296c42c98f0" ], "id": "e-src-18", "locator": "p.13（「共決議參採 17 項青年政策建議」）", "source_id": "src-18", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9cd246ba4572", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-c720d1e44e97" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-19", "locator": "p.3（第七屆委員建議整合歷屆提案、追蹤進度）", "source_id": "src-19", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-c720d1e44e97" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-20", "locator": "p.14（委員 39 位增至 51 位、任期兩年改一年）", "source_id": "src-20", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-21", "locator": "印刷頁碼 p.28（一年任期「恐無法完整參與市政建言從提案至落實階段」，改為兩年）", "source_id": "src-21", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-22", "locator": "p.1 列管案：性暴力倖存者經驗納入第一線人員訓練案解除列管", "source_id": "src-22", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9cd246ba4572", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-b4eea2cf39b5" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-44dc57c63a13" ], "id": "e-src-23", "locator": "p.1 列管表：無障礙臨停案解除列管", "source_id": "src-23", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-b4eea2cf39b5" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-44dc57c63a13" ], "id": "e-src-24", "locator": "p.1 列管表：含豬肉飲食標示案解除列管", "source_id": "src-24", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-b4eea2cf39b5" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-25", "locator": "2026/7/24 質詢速記：青年局主任秘書答「市長出席過 1 次」", "source_id": "src-25", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-3e16f0251c83", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9cd246ba4572" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-26", "locator": "Young people's initiatives 頁（13–17 歲提案、三個月內回覆目標）", "source_id": "src-26", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-f60dc5ee778c" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-90a972d367da" ], "id": "e-src-27", "locator": "§214（2023 年行政規則修正：回覆權責與每年兩次送議會）", "source_id": "src-27", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-f60dc5ee778c" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-90a972d367da" ], "id": "e-src-28", "locator": "評估章節「Nuorten vaikuttamismahdollisuuksien toteutuminen」（2021 年批評提案權落實未追蹤）", "source_id": "src-28", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-29", "locator": "DraftResolution 頁：逐案參採與辦理進度", "source_id": "src-29", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-94f546bdc81a" ], "id": "e-src-30", "locator": "p.1–2（報名資格 16–40 歲；書面審查 30%、面試 70%）", "source_id": "src-30", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-94f546bdc81a" ], "id": "e-src-31", "locator": "p.1（面試名單「佀○洋」）", "source_id": "src-31", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9cd246ba4572" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-32", "locator": "桃園市第 1 選舉區公報：張碩芳經歷欄「第二屆桃園市青年諮詢委員」", "source_id": "src-32", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-d0a26da27d42" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-33", "locator": "p.3–4（張碩芳具名提案）", "source_id": "src-33", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-34", "locator": "p.1（出席委員名單）", "source_id": "src-34", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-47d0a4f6e90e" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-5e569b928dc9" ], "id": "e-src-35", "locator": "111 年桃園市議員選舉公報目錄（14 個選區、131 位候選人經歷欄）", "source_id": "src-35", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-d0a26da27d42" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-36", "locator": "p.1（未曾擔任委員者「得優先錄取」）；p.3（書審「予以送分」）", "source_id": "src-36", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-37", "locator": "論文頁 ID=59（15 位受訪者質性訪談；「會傾向意見相近或較無強勢意見之青年」、「象徵意義大於實質影響力」）", "source_id": "src-37", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-feee8ee3bf0e" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-e6d81aa068b8" ], "id": "e-src-38", "locator": "p.1 第四條（宣傳或支援本府政策）、第七條（損害本府聲譽得解聘）", "source_id": "src-38", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-8cbbf8fb0d77" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-e6d81aa068b8" ], "id": "e-src-39", "locator": "p.4（切結書：「損害臺北市政府聲譽」列為解聘與續聘參酌）", "source_id": "src-39", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-8cbbf8fb0d77" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-40", "locator": "p.6（損害市府聲譽解聘條款）", "source_id": "src-40", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-8cbbf8fb0d77" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-e6d81aa068b8" ], "id": "e-src-41", "locator": "公告內文：委員「各項公眾發言」列為解聘及下屆遴選參據", "source_id": "src-41", "supports": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-8cbbf8fb0d77" ] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-42", "locator": "2022/9/9 報導：市議員質疑青委會委員提案後標案疑流向特定公司", "source_id": "src-42", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-43", "locator": "印刷頁碼 p.189（政風處調查：無委員「自行提案又自行接案」）", "source_id": "src-43", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-44", "locator": "p.35（青諮出席費 612,000 元）；p.46（約僱人員辦理「青年諮詢委員會等業務」）", "source_id": "src-44", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-45", "locator": "p.44（青諮出席費 50 萬元）", "source_id": "src-45", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-ed938e69daa9" ], "id": "e-src-46", "locator": "p.26–27（青諮併入大科目）", "source_id": "src-46", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-ed938e69daa9" ], "id": "e-src-47", "locator": "p.5（「提出 19 件提案」）", "source_id": "src-47", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-48", "locator": "2024 年青年政策網絡招募公告：合格者抽籤、10% 優先名額", "source_id": "src-48", "supports": [] }, { "bounds_unknowns": [], "id": "e-src-49", "locator": "評估報告內文：對中央政策影響不確定、「could be tokenistic」、社經背景較弱青年較少聽過", "source_id": "src-49", "supports": [] } ], "inquiry": { "id": "pursuit_d686bae3d772869c379f", "reader_promise": "桃園第六屆19案中有16案「參採」，但很多案子本來就是市府在做的事，也沒人逐案追到結果；遴選分數和管道沒有公開，「洗履歷」的懷疑查不清，不過2022年公報裡只看到一人把青諮寫進經歷。", "root_question": "桃園、台北青諮會：說要把青年的聲音帶進市府，十年後做到了什麼？", "updated_at": "2026-11-13T08:59:11+00:00" }, "queries": [ { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-54392eb7c842", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-723e9e96255f", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9b5907c0f4b0", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-c720d1e44e97", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-3e16f0251c83", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-b4eea2cf39b5", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-130c02ac56e3", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-d0a26da27d42", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-47d0a4f6e90e", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-8cbbf8fb0d77", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-f60dc5ee778c", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-feee8ee3bf0e", "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9cd246ba4572" ], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-94f546bdc81a", "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-5e569b928dc9", "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-6296c42c98f0", "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-44dc57c63a13", "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-e6d81aa068b8", "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-ed938e69daa9", "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-90a972d367da" ] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-0908d4088633", "text": "桃園、台北青諮會：說要把青年的聲音帶進市府，十年後做到了什麼？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-54392eb7c842" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-54392eb7c842", "text": "桃園第六屆青諮會2025年11月10日的會前會逐案討論19案，主席裁示：納入參採6案、部分參採10案、暫未參採2案、提請市長裁示1案。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-723e9e96255f" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-723e9e96255f", "text": "依我們逐案分類，19案裡至少7案的局處回應指向既有業務。例如AI抓噪音車，環保局原本就已經在用13套AI設備，這案仍被列為「納入參採」。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9b5907c0f4b0" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9b5907c0f4b0", "text": "桃園青年局長在會前會開場說，市長多次希望各組在正式會議前先討論、調整題目，以「降低不參採比例」。第七屆有一組委員的提案網站記錄，提案被「改寫為『政績語言』」，對接既有KPI。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-c720d1e44e97" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-c720d1e44e97", "text": "桃園青年局2025年說會持續向局處追蹤各提案，但2026年3月向議會的工作報告只寫「共決議參採17項青年政策建議」，沒有逐案進度和主責局處。2026年5月第七屆委員再次建議追蹤歷屆提案。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-3e16f0251c83" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-3e16f0251c83", "text": "台北市青年事務委員會成立以來開過6次大會，主任委員是市長，市長只出席過1次。這是青年局主任秘書2026年7月在議會的答詢。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-b4eea2cf39b5" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-b4eea2cf39b5", "text": "台北青委會會以「已配合規劃課程」「已完成示範點改善」「已確立宣導標語」這類理由解除提案列管，紀錄上沒有地點、數量或成效。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-130c02ac56e3" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-130c02ac56e3", "text": "青年辯論賽是委員2025年11月建議市府主辦的，主席裁示2026年試辦，2026年8月底青年盃辯論賽落幕，共16隊參賽。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-d0a26da27d42" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-d0a26da27d42", "text": "2022年桃園市議員選舉14個選區、131位候選人中，選舉公報經歷欄寫了青諮的只有張碩芳一人。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-47d0a4f6e90e" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-47d0a4f6e90e", "text": "在我們讀到的第六屆六份公開紀錄裡（會前會、成立大會紀實、四個小組第一次會議），沒有看到佀廣洋具名提案或發言。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-8cbbf8fb0d77" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-8cbbf8fb0d77", "text": "桃園第六屆切結書要求委員「應適時宣傳或支援本府各項政策」，委員若「有損害本府聲譽之情事」得被解聘。台北、台中也有類似的聲譽條款，台北第二屆還把「各項公眾發言」列為解聘與下屆遴選的參據。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-f60dc5ee778c" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-f60dc5ee778c", "text": "赫爾辛基2023年修正行政規則，青年提案由有權限的委員會回覆，屬市議會或市政府權限的由市長回覆，市府目標是三個月內回覆。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-feee8ee3bf0e" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-feee8ee3bf0e", "text": "一篇訪談15位各級青諮相關人員的研究指出，縣市政府徵選時「會傾向意見相近或較無強勢意見之青年」。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [ "claim-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9cd246ba4572" ], "unknown_ids": [] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-9cd246ba4572", "text": "十年下來，青諮會有開會也有活動，但市府只數得出參採幾案，數不出青年改變了什麼，也說不清委員是怎麼選進去的。" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-94f546bdc81a" ] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-94f546bdc81a", "text": "兩市青諮的評審名單、迴避規定、個人分數，以及各入選管道各錄取幾人？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-5e569b928dc9" ] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-5e569b928dc9", "text": "2026年桃園市議員參選人（包括佀廣洋）有沒有把青諮寫進選舉公報經歷欄？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-6296c42c98f0" ] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-6296c42c98f0", "text": "被參採的提案後來做到哪裡？兩組參與式預算有沒有被正式選上、核支、驗收？辯論賽是不是青諮促成立案的？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-44dc57c63a13" ] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-44dc57c63a13", "text": "台北委員提的「提案動向網站」，為什麼從列管表裡消失？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-e6d81aa068b8" ] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-e6d81aa068b8", "text": "有沒有委員因為批評市府而被解聘或不續聘？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-ed938e69daa9" ] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-ed938e69daa9", "text": "兩市青諮每年實際花了多少錢？" }, { "expects": { "claim_ids": [], "unknown_ids": [ "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-90a972d367da" ] }, "id": "query-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-90a972d367da", "text": "赫爾辛基修規後，青年提案的準時回覆率和成效如何？" } ], "schema": "walkingbook-public-knowledge-v0", "source": { "path": "docs/product/evidence/taiwan-youth-advisory-democratic-representation-editorial-review.md", "sha256": "0b824ced9f5cac0b08e78e39d2af61ced454b4df4cf2b24c03dd59c559a27e8e" }, "sources": [ { "id": "src-1", "published_at": "2026-10-24", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "鏡週刊 2026/10/24", "url": "https://www.mirrormedia.mg/story/20261024-169soc-124233" }, { "id": "src-2", "published_at": "2026-10-24", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "聯合報 2026/10/24", "url": "https://udn.com/news/amp/story/7324/9835297" }, { "id": "src-3", "published_at": "2026-07-06", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社 7/6", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aloc/202607060179.aspx" }, { "id": "src-4", "published_at": "2026-09-03", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社 9/3", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aloc/202609030291.aspx" }, { "id": "src-5", "published_at": "2015-09-01", "source_type": "政府新聞稿", "title": "台北市政府新聞 2015/9/1", "url": "https://www.gov.taipei/News_Content.aspx?n=F0DDAF49B89E9413&s=A908E8155FCC78C3&sms=72544237BBE4C5F6" }, { "id": "src-6", "published_at": "2016-03-22", "source_type": "新聞報導（中央社稿）", "title": "中央社 2016/3/22", "url": "https://n.yam.com/Article/20160322618241" }, { "id": "src-7", "published_at": "2016-03-29", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "自立晚報 2016/3/29", "url": "https://www.idn.com.tw/news/news_content.aspx?artid=20160329ea001" }, { "id": "src-8", "published_at": "2016-03-29", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "台灣好新聞 2016/3/29", "url": "https://n.yam.com/Article/20160329632357" }, { "id": "src-9", "published_at": "", "source_type": "行政規則（設置要點）", "title": "桃園青諮會設置要點 p.1", "url": "https://youthadvisory.yda.gov.tw/upload/placeFiles/MXyYCRsKuC564emLVqAXGms88gD5sMc441TBFPGL.pdf" }, { "id": "src-10", "published_at": "", "source_type": "法規", "title": "全國法規資料庫", "url": "https://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=H0180009" }, { "id": "src-11", "published_at": "", "source_type": "會議紀錄", "title": "會前會紀錄", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?n=MTE0MTExMF%2FnrKzlha3lsYbmoYPlnJLluILmlL%2FlupzpnZLlubToq67oqaLmnIPlhKrpu57lrZDmj5DmoYjmnIPliY3mnIMt5pyD6K2w57SA6YyELeaguOWumi5wZGY%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODQvcmVsZmlsZS8xNDc4NC8xMjMzMDcxLzkxMjE4ZTNkLThiZWUtNGE4MS05N2RmLTIxMTI1YTlkYTlmYy5wZGY%3D" }, { "id": "src-12", "published_at": "", "source_type": "非官方網站（委員小組提案網站）", "title": "國際展望組提案網站", "url": "https://youth7.sup-eric.com/proposal" }, { "id": "src-13", "published_at": "2026-07-04", "source_type": "政府新聞稿", "title": "青年局新聞 2026/7/4", "url": "https://youth.tycg.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=5622&s=1821033&sms=11012" }, { "id": "src-14", "published_at": "2026-08", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "8 月賽事成果", "url": "https://n.yam.com/Article/20260831788240" }, { "id": "src-15", "published_at": "", "source_type": "活動紀實（政府文件）", "title": "工作坊紀實 p.4、21–22", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?n=MTE0MDYwOF%2FnrKzlha3lsYbmoYPlnJLluILmlL%2FlupzpnZLlubToq67oqaLmnIMwNjA46Z2S5bm05o%2BQ5qGI5bel5L2c5Z2K5rS75YuV57SA5a%2BmLeWumOe2si5wZGY%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODQvcmVsZmlsZS8xNDc4NC8xMjMzMDcxL2RhZTVjYTZjLTkxMjEtNDYyYS1hMmQyLWVjMDU1ZWNlYTczNy5wZGY%3D" }, { "id": "src-16", "published_at": "", "source_type": "網站", "title": "青年下班解憂所", "url": "https://youthafterwork.com/" }, { "id": "src-17", "published_at": "", "source_type": "會議紀錄", "title": "小組會議紀錄 p.5", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?n=MTE0MDYyN1%2FmoYPlnJLpnZLlubToq67oqaLlp5Tlk6HnrKzkuIDmrKHmlL%2FnrZbmj5DmoYjmnIPorbDntIDpjIQt5pm65oWn55Sf5rS757WELeaguOWumi5wZGY%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODQvcmVsZmlsZS8xNDc4NC8xMjMzMDcxLzgxZGQxYmJiLWVjMDUtNDE3NS1iYzcxLTI3MmU5YzM1OTk3Mi5wZGY%3D" }, { "id": "src-18", "published_at": "2026-03", "source_type": "議會工作報告", "title": "青年局工作報告 2026/3，p.13", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?icon=.pdf&n=6Z2S5bm05bGA56ysM%2BWxhuesrDfmrKHlrprmnJ%2FmnIPlt6XkvZzloLHlkYoucGRm&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMS9yZWxmaWxlLzc5MjEvMTYxMDMwNy8xMzhkNTY1Yy1iNjVmLTQ0NjctOWRkOC1hMTgyYzczMDg3MzIucGRm" }, { "id": "src-19", "published_at": "", "source_type": "活動紀實（政府文件）", "title": "5 月工作坊紀實 p.3", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODQvcmVsZmlsZS8xNDc4NC8xMjMzMDcxLzI0MTJhOWFiLWI2ZTYtNDBmMy1hNDZjLWYxN2JmN2EzNjRhYy5wZGY%3d&n=MTE1LjA1LjIxX%2besrOS4g%2bWxhuahg%2bWckuW4guaUv%2bW6nOmdkuW5tOirruipouacg%2baPkOahiOWfueWKm%2bW3peS9nOWdiu%2b8iOesrOS4gOWgtOasoe%2b8iS3mtLvli5XntIDlr6YgLSDmoLjlrpoucGRm" }, { "id": "src-20", "published_at": "", "source_type": "議會工作報告", "title": "青年局工作報告 p.14", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?icon=.pdf&n=5qGD5ZyS5biC6K2w5pyD56ysM%2BWxhuesrDPmrKHlrprmnJ%2FmnIPpnZLlubTkuovli5nlsYDlt6XkvZzloLHlkYoucGRm&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMS9yZWxmaWxlLzc5MjEvMTI2MjU4NS84NjFlODcyNy0xNDhkLTQ4YjktYTM2Yy1lYTUwZmVhZDRmNDIucGRm" }, { "id": "src-21", "published_at": "", "source_type": "市府書面答覆（議會議事資料）", "title": "台北市府書面答覆，印刷 p.28", "url": "https://obasfront.tcc.gov.tw/Agenda/DownloadFile.aspx?FileName=202500000404.pdf&FilePath=202501&FileGrpKind=1" }, { "id": "src-22", "published_at": "", "source_type": "會議紀錄", "title": "台北第 5 次會議紀錄 p.1", "url": "https://youth.gov.taipei/api/v1/file.download?file_id=1acbcf73-bfdc-4b7c-a68c-d5b83fd86c38" }, { "id": "src-23", "published_at": "", "source_type": "會議紀錄", "title": "第 6 次", "url": "https://youth.gov.taipei/api/v1/file.download?file_id=7dff5b14-f1b1-49ef-a569-8d79eaef6490" }, { "id": "src-24", "published_at": "", "source_type": "會議紀錄", "title": "第 7 次會議紀錄 p.1", "url": "https://youth.gov.taipei/api/v1/file.download?file_id=040f2b23-21b7-4f19-879d-0992f0360a63" }, { "id": "src-25", "published_at": "2026-07-24", "source_type": "議會速記錄", "title": "台北市議會速記錄 2026/7/24", "url": "https://gaz.tcc.gov.tw/topic-list/h-rr/C5F3CB4AF42988E64EF2CB09EB90EB13/info.html" }, { "id": "src-26", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府網站", "title": "Youth Helsinki", "url": "https://nuorten.hel.fi/en/take-part-and-make-a-difference/young-peoples-initiatives/" }, { "id": "src-27", "published_at": "2023", "source_type": "議會決議", "title": "赫爾辛基市議會決議 §214", "url": "https://paatokset.hel.fi/fi/asia/hel-2023-005606" }, { "id": "src-28", "published_at": "", "source_type": "審計評估報告", "title": "赫爾辛基審計評估", "url": "https://arviointikertomus.fi/kaupunginkanslia/nuorten-vaikuttamismahdollisuuksien-toteutuminen/" }, { "id": "src-29", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府網站（提案資料庫）", "title": "台中青諮提案平台", "url": "https://youth.taichung.gov.tw/DraftResolution" }, { "id": "src-30", "published_at": "", "source_type": "招募簡章", "title": "第六屆報名簡章 p.1–2", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?n=56ys5YWt5bGG5qGD5ZyS5biC5pS%2F5bqc6Z2S5bm06Kuu6Kmi5pyD5aCx5ZCN57Ch56ugLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODQvcmVsZmlsZS8xMTAxMi8xMzczMjc2LzUxYmRlMTMxLTExZmMtNGJlMi1iMDk0LTVkZmM2YzU5YTQxMi5wZGY%3D" }, { "id": "src-31", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府公告（面試名單）", "title": "面試名單 p.1", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?n=56ys5YWt5bGG5qGD5ZyS5biC5pS%2F5bqc6Z2S5bm06Kuu6Kmi5pyD5b616YG46Z2i6Kmm5ZCN5ZauLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODQvcmVsZmlsZS8xMTAxMi8xNDEzMTMzLzBhMTE4MmU0LWM1OTAtNDY1ZS1iYWM1LTEyZWI2YjcxMmI1NC5wZGY%3D" }, { "id": "src-32", "published_at": "", "source_type": "選舉公報", "title": "2022 選舉公報", "url": "https://bulletin.cec.gov.tw/01%E9%81%B8%E8%88%89%E5%85%AC%E5%A0%B1/05%E7%9B%B4%E8%BD%84%E5%B8%82%E8%AD%B0%E5%93%A1/111%E5%B9%B4/03%E6%A1%83%E5%9C%92%E5%B8%82/%E6%A1%83%E5%9C%92%E5%B8%82%E7%AC%AC1%E9%81%B8%E8%88%89%E5%8D%80.pdf" }, { "id": "src-33", "published_at": "", "source_type": "會議紀錄", "title": "第二屆 2020 年 2 月大會紀錄 p.3–4", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?n=MTA55bm0MuaciOWumuacn%2BWkp%2Bacg%2Bacg%2BitsOe0gOmMhC5wZGY%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODQvUmVsRmlsZS8xNDc4NC8xMjMzMDcxLzEwOeW5tDLmnIjlrprmnJ%2FlpKfmnIPmnIPorbDntIDpjIQucGRm" }, { "id": "src-34", "published_at": "", "source_type": "會議紀錄", "title": "公共參與組會議紀錄 p.1", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?n=MTE0MDkxOV%2FmoYPlnJLpnZLlubToq67oqaLlp5Tlk6HlhazlhbHlj4PoiIfntYTnrKzkuIDmrKHmlL%2FnrZbmj5DmoYjnoJTllYbmnIPorbDntIDpjIQt5qC45a6aLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODQvcmVsZmlsZS8xNDc4NC8xMjMzMDcxLzE3MGNjODE4LTlmODMtNDFjOC04ZDUwLTJlOGFiMzA1N2Q3My5wZGY%3D" }, { "id": "src-35", "published_at": "", "source_type": "選舉公報目錄", "title": "2022 桃園市議員選舉公報目錄", "url": "https://bulletin.cec.gov.tw/?dir=01%E9%81%B8%E8%88%89%E5%85%AC%E5%A0%B1/05%E7%9B%B4%E8%BD%84%E5%B8%82%E8%AD%B0%E5%93%A1/111%E5%B9%B4/03%E6%A1%83%E5%9C%92%E5%B8%82" }, { "id": "src-36", "published_at": "", "source_type": "招募簡章", "title": "第七屆遴選簡章 p.1、3", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?n=6YG06YG457Ch56ugLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODEvcmVsZmlsZS8xMDcyNi8xNTk2NjQwLzc2Nzc3OGU5LTgxOGQtNDEzYS04YWQ4LTFkMDljNjY2NmMxNC5wZGY%3D" }, { "id": "src-37", "published_at": "", "source_type": "學術論文", "title": "許雲翔、宋威穎、曾丰彥論文", "url": "https://www.taspaa.org/Paper_Info.aspx?ID=59" }, { "id": "src-38", "published_at": "", "source_type": "切結書", "title": "第六屆切結書 p.1", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?n=56ys5YWt5bGG5qGD5ZyS5biC5pS%2F5bqc6Z2S5bm06Kuu6Kmi5pyD5YiH57WQ5pu4LnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODQvcmVsZmlsZS8xMTAxMi8xMzg3MTc4LzJiMDIwMWRjLWNhMGEtNDhjNS05ZWY1LTY5ODEwZjJiZWI5OS5wZGY%3D" }, { "id": "src-39", "published_at": "", "source_type": "招募簡章", "title": "台北第二屆招募簡章 p.4", "url": "https://www-ws.gov.taipei/Download.ashx?icon=..pdf&n=44CM56ys5LqM5bGG6Ie65YyX5biC6Z2S5bm05LqL5YuZ6Kuu6Kmi5aeU5ZOh5pyD44CN5oub5Yuf57Ch56ugLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvMzAxL3JlbGZpbGUvMTAxNzMvOTcxNzI4My80NzlhNmZlMC00Zjg3LTQ2YzAtYTI0Mi01YWU3MDQ4YzBmMzAucGRm" }, { "id": "src-40", "published_at": "", "source_type": "招募簡章", "title": "台中第四屆遴選簡章 p.6", "url": "https://tcrt.taichung.gov.tw/df_ufiles/030/%E7%AC%AC%E5%9B%9B%E5%B1%86%E9%9D%92%E8%AB%AE%E5%A7%94%E5%93%A1%E9%81%B4%E9%81%B8%E7%B0%A1%E7%AB%A0.pdf" }, { "id": "src-41", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府公告", "title": "台北第二屆招募公告", "url": "https://youth.gov.taipei/theme/4d9d9841-98c5-4c50-9f0c-578e94312898/6703b9a5-882d-49b6-b1ed-94b12dad22fa" }, { "id": "src-42", "published_at": "2022-09-09", "source_type": "新聞報導", "title": "中央社 2022/9/9", "url": "https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aloc/202209090099.aspx" }, { "id": "src-43", "published_at": "2023", "source_type": "市府書面答覆（議會議事資料）", "title": "市府書面答覆，印刷 p.189", "url": "https://obasfront.tcc.gov.tw/Agenda/DownloadFile.aspx?FileName=202300002055.pdf&FilePath=202307&FileGrpKind=1" }, { "id": "src-44", "published_at": "", "source_type": "預算書", "title": "桃園青年局 115 年度預算 p.35、46", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?n=MTE15bm05bqm6aCQ566XLnBkZg%3D%3D&u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODQvcmVsZmlsZS8xNDgxMS8xNTg1MzIyL2NmOGQzMDMyLWM4ODctNDU5Ny1hYmUzLTljMzkzZjYzYmMzYS5wZGY%3D" }, { "id": "src-45", "published_at": "", "source_type": "預算書", "title": "台北青年局 115 年度預算 p.44", "url": "https://youth.gov.taipei/api/v1/file.download?file_id=fee93cb2-3a59-41a2-820d-b78b9f14519b" }, { "id": "src-46", "published_at": "", "source_type": "決算書", "title": "桃園 114 年度決算 p.26–27", "url": "https://ws.tycg.gov.tw/Download.ashx?u=LzAwMS9VcGxvYWQvODQvcmVsZmlsZS8xNDgxMS8xNjA4OTEyL2ZhNzVlYzVjLWUxZWItNDYyNS1iODhkLWZkYzNhNzY0NDA2ZC5wZGY%3d&n=MTE05bm05bqm5rG6566XZm9y5LiK5YKzLnBkZg%3d%3d" }, { "id": "src-47", "published_at": "", "source_type": "決算書", "title": "台北 114 年度決算總說明 p.5", "url": "https://youth.gov.taipei/api/v1/file.download?file_id=51fecbb0-f764-4e13-8caf-c8106a65d8bd" }, { "id": "src-48", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府公告", "title": "首爾市招募公告", "url": "https://youth.seoul.go.kr/bbs/view.do?key=2303300002&pstSn=2403040002" }, { "id": "src-49", "published_at": "", "source_type": "政府委託評估報告", "title": "英國青年議會評估", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/evaluation-of-the-uk-youth-parliament/evaluation-of-the-uk-youth-parliament" } ], "unknowns": [ { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "桃園市青年事務局公開第六、七屆評審名單、迴避紀錄和各管道錄取人數，或依政府資訊公開申請提供。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-1", "e-src-2", "e-src-30", "e-src-31" ], "id": "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-94f546bdc81a", "question": "兩市青諮的評審名單、迴避規定、個人分數，以及各入選管道各錄取幾人？", "status": "not_requested" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "中選會公報目錄上架2026年桃園市議員選舉公報，並逐區讀完經歷欄。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-35" ], "id": "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-5e569b928dc9", "question": "2026年桃園市議員參選人（包括佀廣洋）有沒有把青諮寫進選舉公報經歷欄？", "status": "world_pending" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "桃園青年局公開逐案執行表、2026年3月之後的議會工作報告，或公開參與式預算核支紀錄和辯論賽立案簽呈。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-11", "e-src-13", "e-src-15", "e-src-16", "e-src-18" ], "id": "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-6296c42c98f0", "question": "被參採的提案後來做到哪裡？兩組參與式預算有沒有被正式選上、核支、驗收？辯論賽是不是青諮促成立案的？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "台北市青年局在後續會議紀錄或議會答覆裡說明撤除列管的理由。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-23", "e-src-24" ], "id": "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-44dc57c63a13", "question": "台北委員提的「提案動向網站」，為什麼從列管表裡消失？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "三市青年局公開歷屆解聘、不續聘的案例和理由，或當事人提出可核實的說法。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-38", "e-src-39", "e-src-41" ], "id": "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-e6d81aa068b8", "question": "有沒有委員因為批評市府而被解聘或不續聘？", "status": "public_not_found" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "兩市決算拆出青諮的委辦費、出席費和人力的實支金額。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-46", "e-src-47" ], "id": "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-ed938e69daa9", "question": "兩市青諮每年實際花了多少錢？", "status": "bounded_unknown" }, { "changes_claim_ids": [], "closure": "赫爾辛基審計委員會或市府公布2023年修規後的回覆時效統計。", "evidence_refs": [ "e-src-27", "e-src-28" ], "id": "unknown-youth-advisory-council-taoyuan-taipei-90a972d367da", "question": "赫爾辛基修規後，青年提案的準時回覆率和成效如何？", "status": "public_not_found" } ] }